Shelter Island (NY) hotels and places to stay

Search among 25 available hotels and places to stay in Shelter Island from 50+ providers

Check-in
Sat, 20 Jul
-
Check-out
Sun, 21 Jul
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Check-in
Sat, 20 Jul
-
Check-out
Sun, 21 Jul
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
Check-in
Sat, 20 Jul
-
Check-out
Sun, 21 Jul
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
View map
1-25 out of 25
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
8.6
Great43 reviews
Map
1.9 mi from City Center
Featuring a heated swimming pool and 33 rooms, the Pridwin is within 2.3 miles of Greenport Antique Carousel.
FromUS$ 334 /nightSelect
8.6
Great8 reviews
Map
1.2 mi from City Center
Founders Landing Park is approximately 2.9 miles from the 4-star Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island and Dering Harbor Marina is about a 20-minute stroll away.
FromUS$ 823 /nightSelect
8.2
Great9 reviews
Map
2.4 mi from City Center
Dering Harbor Marina and Sylvester Manor Educational Farm are located 2.8 miles and 2.3 miles from the Rams Head Shelter Island respectively.
FromUS$ 407 /nightSelect
Hotel
7.8
Very good26 reviews
Map
1.5 mi from City Center
Greenport Antique Carousel is within a 10-minute drive of the Sunset Beach, while Fireboat Firefighter Museum is 10 minutes' drive away.
FromUS$ 596 /nightSelect
Places to stay near Shelter Island
Hotel
8.4
Great59 reviews
Map
5.1 mi from Shelter Island5.1 mi from City Center
Set just walking distance from Custom House Museum, the 4-star luxury Baron'S Cove Sag Harbor offers a seasonal outdoor pool together with fitness classes and spa therapy for guest enjoyment.
FromUS$ 219 /nightSelect
8.4
Great54 reviews
Map
2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing city and the 4-star American Beech is set less than a 6-minute stroll from Greenport Antique Carousel.
FromUS$ 289 /nightSelect
8.4
Great62 reviews
Map
3.6 mi from Shelter Island3.6 mi from City Center
The Sound View Greenport overlooks the ocean and boasts a location in a beach area.
FromUS$ 849 /nightSelect
8.4
Great51 reviews
Map
2.6 mi from Shelter Island2.6 mi from City Center
Railroad Museum of Long Island is a 5-minute walk away and Kontokosta Winery can be reached within 10 minutes by car.
FromUS$ 329 /nightSelect
8.0
Great24 reviews
Map
2.6 mi from Shelter Island2.6 mi from City Center
Positioned within 900 feet of Railroad Museum of Long Island, the Menhaden Greenport has 15 rooms, the à la carte restaurant serving the Mediterranean cuisine, all at guest's disposal.
FromUS$ 499 /nightSelect
8.4
Great40 reviews
Map
2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
The 3-star Greenporter Greenport is set 10 minutes' drive from Shelter Island and 700 feet from Fireboat Firefighter Museum.
FromUS$ 170 /nightSelect
8.6
Great20 reviews
Map
1.2 mi from Shelter Island1.2 mi from City Center
The 4-star Shelter Island House Shelter Island Heights is located around 10 minutes by foot from Crescent Beach and comprises 11 rooms with modern comforts.
FromUS$ 362 /nightSelect
7.4
Very good9 reviews
Map
3.9 mi from Shelter Island3.9 mi from City Center
The 3-star Blue Inn At North Fork East Marion is set about 1.6 miles from East End Seaport Maritime Museum and 1.5 miles from Greenport.
FromUS$ 186 /nightSelect
8.6
Great28 reviews
Map
1.4 mi from Shelter Island1.4 mi from City Center
Featuring 33 rooms with views of the sea, the Chequit Shelter Island Heights is set approximately 1.4 miles from Shelter Island.
FromUS$ 668 /nightSelect
Bed & Breakfast
8.4
Great16 reviews
Map
1.2 mi from Shelter Island1.2 mi from City Center
East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation is about a 25-minute walk away and Greenport Antique Carousel can be reached within 10 minutes by car.
FromUS$ 378 /nightSelect
8.6
Great16 reviews
Map
2.5 mi from Shelter Island2.5 mi from City Center
Shelter Island is set within a 10-minute drive of the 3-star Harbor Knoll Bed And Breakfast Greenport.
FromUS$ 718 /nightSelect
8.4
Great11 reviews
Map
3.4 mi from Shelter Island3.4 mi from City Center
While staying at the 4-star Shoals Suites & Slips you are invited to discover Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum, set about 2.3 miles away, or Fireboat Firefighter Museum, which is 2.6 miles away.
FromUS$ 199 /nightSelect
8.0
Great2 reviews
Map
2.5 mi from Shelter Island2.5 mi from City Center
Offering convenient proximity to Railroad Museum of Long Island, the hotel is also close to Kontokosta Winery.
Select
8.6
Great32 reviews
Map
2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
Placed 53 miles from Long Island MacArthur airport, the 4-star Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport features a restaurant and baggage storage as well as bicycles for rent.
FromUS$ 666 /nightSelect
8.4
Great29 reviews
Map
3.6 mi from Shelter Island3.6 mi from City Center
Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum is within 4 miles of the 3-star Walk In The Woods and Southold Bay Oysters is just 0.9 miles away.
FromUS$ 345 /nightSelect
8.2
Great10 reviews
Map
5.1 mi from Shelter Island5.1 mi from City Center
The 3-star Sag Harbors Inn Sag Harbor is set 3.6 miles from South Fork Natural History Museum and Nature Center and 10 minutes by foot from The Windmill.
FromUS$ 429 /nightSelect
Bed & Breakfast
8.0
Great20 reviews
Map
2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
Featuring 10 rooms with views of the garden, the Zey Greenport is set 10 minutes' drive from Sylvester Manor Educational Farm.
FromUS$ 375 /nightSelect
9.4
Perfect2 reviews
Map
3.5 mi from Shelter Island3.5 mi from City Center
Set about a 25-minute walk from Fireboat Firefighter Museum, the rooms in the Moraine have views of sea.
FromUS$ 768 /nightSelect
Map
2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
Shelter Island is 2.6 miles from the Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows Greenport and Fireboat Firefighter Museum is about 1 miles away.
FromUS$ 525 /nightSelect
8.6
Great34 reviews
Map
4.1 mi from Shelter Island4.1 mi from City Center
The smoke free Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast East Marion is set 0.6 miles from Lavender By the Bay and within 2.2 miles of Greenport Antique Carousel.
FromUS$ 406 /nightSelect
Map
3.2 mi from Shelter Island3.2 mi from City Center
Featuring free self parking and a picnic area, this property is situated a short distance from Greenport Farmers' Market.
Select

FAQs about hotels in Shelter Island

We hope that the answers to these questions will help you plan your trip

Which hotels for couples in Shelter Island are the best to stay at?

According to Booked.net travel data, there are 3 deals for couples. Check Rams Head Inn rated 8.2/10 with a picnic area, cribs, and yoga classes. It’s set 2.8 miles from Dering Harbor Marina and costs about 407US$ per night. For more romantic deals go here.

What are the most favored hotels in Shelter Island?

You may like The Pridwin Hotel rated 8.6/10 featuring a seasonal outdoor pool, back massages, and concierge service. It costs 334US$ per night. Alternatively, you may like Seven - A Boutique B&B On with a golf course, full body massage, and a seasonal outdoor pool. It costs 823US$ per night.

What are the best luxury properties in Shelter Island?

Check Sunset Beach rated 7.8/10 at the cost of 596US$ per night. It's located 0.3 miles from Crescent Beach and provides ironing, restaurant, and bar.

Which spa hotels in Shelter Island would you recommend?

You may book The Pridwin Hotel, a nice spa hotel featuring a seasonal outdoor pool, back massages, and concierge service. It costs 334US$ per night. As an alternative, book Rams Head Inn (rating: 8.2/10), which costs 407US$ per night and offers a picnic area, cribs, and yoga classes.

How much does it cost to stay in a hotel in Shelter Island?

Of course, the prices change in Shelter Island depending on the season, but on average:
A 3-star hotel room costs 407US$ per night, for instance, check Rams Head Inn with a picnic area, cribs, and yoga classes.
A 4-star hotel room costs 823US$ per night. You may book Seven - A Boutique B&B On with a picnic area, a golf course, and full body massage.

How much is a hotel in Shelter Island for tonight?

According to Booked.net travel data, the average Shelter Island prices for tonight are:
The Pridwin Hotel (rating: 8.6/10) may cost you about 334US$ per night.

Shelter Island hotels essential information

🏨 Hotels in Shelter Island 25
👛 Lowest price 170 USD
✍️ Hotels Reviews 605