Check rooms and rates
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Sorry, we don't recognize this name.Enter a destination to start the search
We can’t find that destination
Try to change your search
The Internet connection seems to be slow. It may take a few more seconds to load the page. Thank you for your patience.
×
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room

Shelter Island (NY) hotels and places to stay

Search among 69 available hotels and places to stay in Shelter Island from 50+ providers.

Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Sorry, we don't recognize this name.Enter a destination to start the search
We can’t find that destination
Try to change your search
The Internet connection seems to be slow. It may take a few more seconds to load the page. Thank you for your patience.
×
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Sorry, we don't recognize this name.Enter a destination to start the search
We can’t find that destination
Try to change your search
The Internet connection seems to be slow. It may take a few more seconds to load the page. Thank you for your patience.
×
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Sorry, we don't recognize this name.Enter a destination to start the search
We can’t find that destination
Try to change your search
The Internet connection seems to be slow. It may take a few more seconds to load the page. Thank you for your patience.
×
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room
03Dec2022Saturday
04Dec2022Sunday
Get Prices
0Filter by
View map
Sort by
View map
1-69 out of 69
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
  • The hotel has
    • Free Wi-Fi in public areas
  • The hotel has
    • On-site car park
  • The hotel has
    • 24-hour reception
  • The hotel has
    • Bar/ Lounge area
    • Restaurant
    • Welcome drink
View on map1.9 mi from City Center1000 yd from City Center
Featuring a private pool and views of the bay, the property offers guests to enjoy American meals and take advantage of its location in Shelter Island.
8.0
Great4 reviews
From   US$ 334 /nightSelect
Not available
  • The hotel has
    • Bar/ Lounge area
    • Restaurant
  • The hotel has
    • Flat-screen TV
View on map1.5 mi from City Center100 yd from City Center
Set within easy reach of Mashomack Preserve, the venue features a beachfront restaurant serving meals of French cuisine.
7.6
Very good26 reviews
From   US$ 596 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map1.6 mi from City Center400 yd from City Center
Select
Not available
Similar properties near Shelter Island
View on map5.1 mi from Shelter Island5.1 mi from City Center
The hotel is set close to North Haven Village Park, and boasts a salt water swimming pool as well as patio views.
8.0
Great18 reviews
From   US$ 237 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
Offering convenient proximity to Nova Constellatio Gallery, the hotel is also close to Kontokosta Winery.
7.8
Very good12 reviews
From   US$ 189 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map3.6 mi from Shelter Island3.6 mi from City Center
Located just 2.6 km from Fireboat Firefighter Museum, this hotel features a sunbathing terrace, a shared lounge and a golf course for guests' convenience.
7.8
Very good11 reviews
From   US$ 140 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.6 mi from Shelter Island2.6 mi from City Center
Set near Kontokosta Winery, this central venue is 10 minutes' walk of the city center.
8.4
Great7 reviews
From   US$ 185 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
Within easy reach of Kontokosta Winery, this hotel comprises 30 rooms with en suite bathrooms.
8.0
Great7 reviews
From   US$ 129 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.6 mi from Shelter Island2.6 mi from City Center
The luxury hotel is a good starting point to Greenport' sights including Kontokosta Winery and Congregation Tifereth Israel.
From   US$ 259 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map4.1 mi from Shelter Island4.1 mi from City Center
Placed a 10-minute walk from East Marion's city centre, the villa features a sunbathing terrace, a library and a golf course.
From   US$ 571 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map1.2 mi from Shelter Island1.2 mi from City Center500 yd from City Center
Located next to Shelter Island Tours & Transportation, the venue comprises 9 rooms with garden views.
8.6
Great
From   US$ 612 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.5 mi from Shelter Island2.5 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the sea and the hotel is set close to Sylvester Manor Educational Farm.
7.6
Very good3 reviews
From   US$ 623 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
Situated in a beach area of Greenport, this hotel features a summer terrace and a shared lounge.
7.6
Very good4 reviews
From   US$ 283 /nightSelect
Not available
Bed & Breakfast
View on map1.2 mi from Shelter Island1.2 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the garden and the hotel is set close to Railroad Museum of Long Island.
From   US$ 147 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map1.4 mi from Shelter Island1.4 mi from City Center
The hotel offers easy access to East End Seaport Maritime Museum, boasting 14 rooms in the heart of Shelter Island Heights.
8.6
Great
From   US$ 589 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map4.0 mi from Shelter Island4.0 mi from City Center
This property is 3.3 km from Camera Obscura and welcomes its guests to enjoy mini golf and fishing.
From   US$ 550 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map3.6 mi from Shelter Island3.6 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the mountain and the hotel is set close to Custer Institute & Observatory.
7.8
Very good3 reviews
From   US$ 320 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map4.3 mi from Shelter Island4.3 mi from City Center
Offering a fully equipped kitchen complete with a microwave, a dishwasher and a refrigerator, this villa is located close to Bible Baptist Church.
From   US$ 340 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map3.5 mi from Shelter Island3.5 mi from City Center
Set within 30 minutes' walk of the city center, the apartment offers a mini-kitchen along with a terrace.
8.2
Great19 reviews
From   US$ 269 /nightSelect
Not available
Bed & Breakfast
View on map1.0 mi from Shelter Island1.0 mi from City Center900 yd from City Center
A few meters away you can enjoy Shelter Island Craft Brewery.
From   US$ 209 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map4.1 mi from Shelter Island4.1 mi from City Center
One can feel the benefits of aromatherapy and massage, while staying in this property, placed in a busy area of East Marion and close to Oysterponds Historical Society.
9.0
Perfect27 reviews
From   US$ 335 /nightSelect
Not available
Homestay
View on map6.9 mi from Shelter Island6.9 mi from City Center
From   US$ 250 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map4.7 mi from Shelter Island4.7 mi from City Center
Sag Harbor is 1.3 miles from this villa that offers 5 bedrooms along with a fully-fitted kitchen.
Select
Not available
View on map2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
Placed 1.6 miles from Our Lady of the Isle Church, the property consists of 1 bedrooms, 1 bathrooms and a kitchen.
From   US$ 214 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map3.2 mi from Shelter Island3.2 mi from City Center
Situated in East Marion next to Greenport Fire, this property features cots, playpens and board games for families with children.
From   US$ 1 450 /nightSelect
Not available
Bed & Breakfast
View on map5.5 mi from Shelter Island5.5 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
Bed & Breakfast
View on map5.5 mi from Shelter Island5.5 mi from City Center
From   US$ 200 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map6.3 mi from Shelter Island6.3 mi from City Center
Conscience Point Historic Site is 7 km from this villa that offers 5 bedrooms along with a kitchen.
From   US$ 3 309 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map5.9 mi from Shelter Island5.9 mi from City Center
Offering a kitchen equipped with a microwave oven, a dishwasher and a fridge, this villa is set near Out of the Closet.
From   US$ 1 077 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map5.9 mi from Shelter Island5.9 mi from City Center
From   US$ 176 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map5.4 mi from Shelter Island5.4 mi from City Center
Offering a fully equipped kitchen complete with a dishwasher, a refrigerator and a washing machine, this villa is located close to Ark Project Inc.
From   US$ 620 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
This is a 3-bedroom villa, set in proximity to Camera Obscura.
From   US$ 483 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
Located in Greenport, and a short stroll from Greenport Harbor Brewing Company, this venue includes a fully furnished kitchen with a microwave and a dishwasher, as well as 1 bathrooms.
From   US$ 263 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map6.9 mi from Shelter Island6.9 mi from City Center
Offering a fully equipped kitchen complete with a microwave oven, a dishwasher and a refrigerator, this villa is located close to The Hampton Classic.
From   US$ 2 616 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map6.6 mi from Shelter Island6.6 mi from City Center
Offering a kitchen equipped with a microwave oven, coffee/tea making facilities and an oven, this villa is set near Children's Museum of The East End.
Select
Not available
View on map8.4 mi from Shelter Island8.4 mi from City Center
Atlantic Avenue Beach is 16 km from this villa that offers 5 bedrooms along with a full kitchen.
From   US$ 2 998 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map8.0 mi from Shelter Island8.0 mi from City Center
Situated a 20-minute drive to North Main Street Historic District, this villa features a balcony and a terrace.
From   US$ 3 573 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map6.9 mi from Shelter Island6.9 mi from City Center
Located 1 miles from path continues, this villa offers a cable flat-screen and a flat screen TV together with 4 bathrooms.
From   US$ 2 073 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map7.8 mi from Shelter Island7.8 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
View on map2.9 mi from Shelter Island2.9 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
View on map6.1 mi from Shelter Island6.1 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
View on map2.6 mi from Shelter Island2.6 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
View on map3.4 mi from Shelter Island3.4 mi from City Center
Situated 1.7 miles from Nova Constellatio Gallery, the villa offers snow skiing and horse riding.
From   US$ 1 219 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map8.2 mi from Shelter Island8.2 mi from City Center
From   US$ 10 949 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map7.9 mi from Shelter Island7.9 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
View on map5.0 mi from Shelter Island5.0 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
View on map5.3 mi from Shelter Island5.3 mi from City Center
From   US$ 718 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map4.2 mi from Shelter Island4.2 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
View on map8.3 mi from Shelter Island8.3 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
View on map7.2 mi from Shelter Island7.2 mi from City Center
From   US$ 317 /nightSelect
Not available
Homestay
View on map5.5 mi from Shelter Island5.5 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
View on map3.3 mi from Shelter Island3.3 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
View on map5.7 mi from Shelter Island5.7 mi from City Center
From   US$ 520 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map9.3 mi from Shelter Island9.3 mi from City Center
The property provides complimentary newspapers and a fire extinguisher and is set 2.3 miles from the city center.
Select
Not available
View on map8.4 mi from Shelter Island8.4 mi from City Center
LongHouse Reserve is 1 miles from this villa that offers 1 bedrooms along with a fully-fitted kitchen.
Select
Not available
View on map7.0 mi from Shelter Island7.0 mi from City Center
Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge is 2.8 miles from this villa that offers 6 bedrooms along with a kitchen.
Select
Not available
View on map2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
Composed of 3 bedrooms and 1 bathrooms, this vacation home is set only 0.4 miles from Railroad Museum of Long Island.
From   US$ 530 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map3.6 mi from Shelter Island3.6 mi from City Center
Railroad Museum of Long Island is 1.7 miles from this villa that offers 3 bedrooms along with a kitchen.
From   US$ 700 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map3.4 mi from Shelter Island3.4 mi from City Center
This villa is a 10-minute drive from Railroad Museum of Long Island and offers horse riding and skiing.
From   US$ 934 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map5.5 mi from Shelter Island5.5 mi from City Center
The Hampton Classic is 3.7 miles from this villa that offers 3 bedrooms along with an equipped kitchen.
From   US$ 700 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map5.2 mi from Shelter Island5.2 mi from City Center
Being within 1.4 miles of Foster Memorial Town Beach, this villa features a sunny patio.
From   US$ 1 265 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map5.0 mi from Shelter Island5.0 mi from City Center
Being within 2.8 miles of Greenport, this villa features a shared lounge.
Select
Not available
View on map7.0 mi from Shelter Island7.0 mi from City Center
Located about 1.7 miles from Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum, the villa offers accommodation for 8 guests.
From   US$ 2 213 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map6.6 mi from Shelter Island6.6 mi from City Center
Located 2.6 miles from Children's Museum of The East End, the villa features a cable flat-screen, a bar and a flat screen TV.
From   US$ 13 077 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map7.1 mi from Shelter Island7.1 mi from City Center
Set within walking distance of Ark Project Inc, this villa includes 7 bedrooms and an equipped kitchen for guests' convenience.
From   US$ 7 242 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map6.8 mi from Shelter Island6.8 mi from City Center
Situated less than 10 minutes' drive from Bridge Gardens, this villa features a cable flat-screen and a flat screen TV.
Select
Not available
View on map5.9 mi from Shelter Island5.9 mi from City Center
Located about 1 miles from Schiavoni's Market Inc, the villa offers accommodation for 8 guests.
From   US$ 7 499 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map5.3 mi from Shelter Island5.3 mi from City Center
Located 1 miles from Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge, the villa features a cable flat-screen and a flat screen TV.
Select
Not available
View on map5.7 mi from Shelter Island5.7 mi from City Center
From   US$ 641 /nightSelect
Not available

Filtering results

Please wait...

69 hotels found

FAQs about hotels in Shelter Island

We hope that the answers to these questions will help you plan your trip

What are the top Shelter Island hotels for couples?

According to Booked.net travel data, there are 3 deals for couples. The Pridwin Hotel rated 8.0/10 is a favorite 4-star hotel for couples, featuring full body massage, a seasonal outdoor pool and back massages. Travelers can book a room at this property for about 364US$ per night. Go here to check more romantic accommodations.

Which hotels are the best ones to stay at in Shelter Island?

For instance, book Sunset Beach rated 7.6/10 for 596US$ per night. It's set 2.5 miles from Founders Landing Park and provides ironing, restaurant and bar. The Pridwin Hotel rated 8.0/10 may also suit you — only 364US$ per one night. It features full body massage, a seasonal outdoor pool and back massages.

Which spa hotels in Shelter Island would you recommend?

You may book The Pridwin Hotel, a nice spa hotel featuring full body massage, a seasonal outdoor pool and a spa lounge. It costs 364US$ per night.

How much is an average Shelter Island hotel price?

Of course, the prices change in Shelter Island depending on the season, but on average:
A 4-star hotel room costs 364US$ per night. You may check The Pridwin Hotel with full body massage, a seasonal outdoor pool and a spa lounge.