Check rooms and rates
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room

Best Shelter Island NY hotels, motels and accommodations of 2020

Search the best hotels and places to stay in Shelter Island

View map
Filter by
Sort by
  • Sort by
  • Pricefrom low to highfrom high to low
  • Popularityfrom low to highfrom high to low
  • Guest ratingfrom low to highfrom high to low
Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11965View on map
1.4 mi from City Center200 yd from City Center
Set within easy reach of Mashomack Preserve, the venue features a beachfront restaurant serving meals of French cuisine.
  • The hotel has
    • Free internet access
    +1
  • The hotel has
    • 24-hour reception
    +1
7.6
Very good21 reviews
Price fromUS$ 596per nightSelect
Not available
Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island7 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11965View on map
1.2 mi from City Center500 yd from City Center
The hotel was built in 1902 in a natural area of Shelter Island, and nowadays has 44.
  • The bed & breakfast has
    • On-site car park
    +1
9.8
Perfect2 reviews
Price fromUS$ 440per nightSelect
Not available
Romantic Shelter Island Cottage W/2 Pools & A PondVillaShelter Island, Ny, 11964, Shelter Island, United States, 11964View on map
1.7 mi from City Center1.1 mi from City Center
Offering a fully-fitted kitchen equipped with a microwave oven, a dishwasher and a fridge, this villa is set near The Village Blacksmith.
Select
Not available
Luxurious 'Shelter Island Hideaway' W/ Pool!VillaShelter Island, Ny, 11964, Shelter Island, United States, 11964View on map
1.7 mi from City Center1.1 mi from City Center
This beachfront villa with 4 bedrooms is available for 10 guests in proximity of Manhansett Chapel Museum.
Select
Not available
Similar properties near Shelter Island
The Greenporter Hotel326 Front Street, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
Within easy reach of Kontokosta Winery, this hotel comprises 30 rooms with en suite bathrooms.
8.8
Great3 reviews
Price fromUS$ 298per nightSelect
Not available
The Harborfront Inn209 Front Street, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
2.6 mi from Shelter Island2.6 mi from City Center
Set near Kontokosta Winery, this central venue is 10 minutes' walk of the city center.
9.6
Perfect1 review
Price fromUS$ 394per nightSelect
Not available
The Blue Inn At North Fork7850 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939View on map
3.9 mi from Shelter Island3.9 mi from City Center
Just off Camera Obscura, this hotel offers a beautiful location and includes an indoor restaurant.
8.0
Great9 reviews
Price fromUS$ 189per nightSelect
Not available
Topping Rose House1 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, United States, 11932View on map
9.2 mi from Shelter Island9.2 mi from City Center
Located steps from Round Swamp Farm in Bridgehampton, this 22-room hotel with antique décor boasts a summer terrace, a library and a golf course.
8.2
Great3 reviews
Price fromUS$ 1 628per nightSelect
Not available
The Pridwin Hotel81 Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights, United States, 11964View on map
1.9 mi from Shelter Island1.9 mi from City Center
Featuring a private pool and views of the bay, the property offers guests to enjoy American meals and take advantage of its location in Shelter Island.
9.2
Perfect1 review
Price fromUS$ 679per nightSelect
Not available
Townsend Manor Inn714 Main Street, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
3.1 mi from Shelter Island3.1 mi from City Center
Located just off Camera Obscura and 47 km from Mystic, this hotel features a cocktail lounge and a golf course.
7.4
Very good6 reviews
Price fromUS$ 253per nightSelect
Not available
Heron Suites61600 Main Road, Southold, United States, 11791View on map
3.5 mi from Shelter Island3.5 mi from City Center
This hotel offers the coffee bar and 20 rooms together with convenient location close to One Woman Wines & Vineyards.
8.2
Great14 reviews
Price fromUS$ 256per nightSelect
Not available
White Fences Inn371 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, United StatesView on map
11.3 mi from Shelter Island11.3 mi from City Center
Offering garden views, the venue is placed close to Our Lady of Poland Catholic Church, and boasts a private pool.
Price fromUS$ 498per nightSelect
Not available
Shorecrest Bed And Breakfast54300 County Road, 48, Southold, United States, 11971View on map
4.1 mi from Shelter Island4.1 mi from City Center
At this venue, boasting a location in a beach area, guests can enjoy a shared lounge, a library and a golf course, or explore The Old Field Vineyards nearby.
Price fromUS$ 306per nightSelect
Not available
Quintessentials Bed And Breakfast And Spa8985 Main Road, P.O. Box 574, East Marion, United States, 11939View on map
4.0 mi from Shelter Island4.0 mi from City Center
Featuring Turkish bath and massage treatments, this business hotel is located less than 2.3 km from Kontokosta Winery.
Price fromUS$ 331per nightSelect
Not available
Cliffside Resort CondominiumsApartment61475 Route 48, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
3.5 mi from Shelter Island3.5 mi from City Center
Set within 30 minutes' walk of the city center, the apartment offers a mini-kitchen along with a terrace.
Price fromUS$ 433per nightSelect
Not available
380 Inn380 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott, United States, 11975View on map
9.5 mi from Shelter Island9.5 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the garden and the hotel is set close to South Fork Natural History Museum.
7.2
Very good6 reviews
Price fromUS$ 215per nightSelect
Not available
The Chequit Inn23 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights, United States, 11965View on map
1.4 mi from Shelter Island1.4 mi from City Center
The hotel offers easy access to East End Seaport Maritime Museum, boasting 14 rooms in the heart of Shelter Island Heights.
Price fromUS$ 288per nightSelect
Not available
Baron'S Cove31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963View on map
5.1 mi from Shelter Island5.1 mi from City Center
The hotel is set close to North Haven Village Park, and boasts a salt water swimming pool as well as patio views.
9.6
Perfect1 review
Price fromUS$ 751per nightSelect
Not available
The Stirling House B&B Greenport104 Bay Avenue, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
Situated in a beach area of Greenport, this hotel features a summer terrace and a shared lounge.
Price fromUS$ 381per nightSelect
Not available
Bridge Inn2668 Montauk Highway , Bridgehampton, United States, 11932View on map
9.2 mi from Shelter Island9.2 mi from City Center
The hotel offers easy access to South Fork Natural History Museum, boasting 10 rooms in the heart of Bridgehampton.
6.2
Nice3 reviews
Price fromUS$ 302per nightSelect
Not available
Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast8900 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939View on map
4.1 mi from Shelter Island4.1 mi from City Center
One can feel the benefits of aromatherapy and massage, while staying in this property, placed in a busy area of East Marion and close to Oysterponds Historical Society.
9.4
Perfect22 reviews
Price fromUS$ 349per nightSelect
Not available
Southold Beach Motel53250 North Road, Southold, United StatesView on map
4.2 mi from Shelter Island4.2 mi from City Center
This hotel features rooms with garden views, while a convenient location provides easy access to The Old Field Vineyards.
Select
Not available
Forever Bungalows765 Rt 114, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963View on map
6.5 mi from Shelter Island6.5 mi from City Center
Set in the centre of Sag Harbor, the property offers 14 rooms overlooking the city.
Price fromUS$ 565per nightSelect
Not available
A Walk In The Woods Bed And Breakfast9680 North Bayview Road, Southold, United States, 11971View on map
3.6 mi from Shelter Island3.6 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the mountain and the hotel is set close to Custer Institute & Observatory.
Price fromUS$ 270per nightSelect
Not available
American Beech Hotel300 Main Street, Greenport, United StatesView on map
2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
Offering convenient proximity to Nova Constellatio Gallery, the hotel is also close to Kontokosta Winery.
Price fromUS$ 466per nightSelect
Not available
Bridgehampton Inn2266 Main St, Bridgehampton, United StatesView on map
9.3 mi from Shelter Island9.3 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the garden and the hotel is set close to Madoo Conservancy.
Price fromUS$ 452per nightSelect
Not available
Orient Inn25-500 Main Road, Orient, United StatesView on map
5.9 mi from Shelter Island5.9 mi from City Center
This historical hotel overlooks the garden boasting its location in busy area.
Price fromUS$ 295per nightSelect
Not available
Sound View Greenport58775 Route 48, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
3.6 mi from Shelter Island3.6 mi from City Center
Located just 2.6 km from Fireboat Firefighter Museum, this hotel features a sunbathing terrace, a shared lounge and a golf course for guests' convenience.
Price fromUS$ 446per nightSelect
Not available
Ram'S Head Inn108 South Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island Heights, United States, NY 11965View on map
2.4 mi from Shelter Island2.4 mi from City Center
Located a few steps from Manhansett Chapel Museum, the hotel features 13 rooms with views over the garden.
Price fromUS$ 429per nightSelect
Not available
Wickham Prince Bed And Breakfast1100 Youngs Avenue, Southold, United States, NY 11971View on map
4.6 mi from Shelter Island4.6 mi from City Center
In the vicinity of this luxury hotel there is Southold Bay Oysters and guests can also discover the coastal area.
Price fromUS$ 267per nightSelect
Not available
The Wells HouseApartment530 Main Street, Greenport, United States, NY 11944View on map
2.9 mi from Shelter Island2.9 mi from City Center
The budget hotel is a good starting point to Greenport' sights including Greenport Farmers' Market and Fireboat Firefighter Museum.
Price fromUS$ 429per nightSelect
Not available
Shelter Island House11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, United StatesView on map
1.2 mi from Shelter Island1.2 mi from City Center
Located next to Shelter Island Tours & Transportation, the venue comprises 9 rooms with garden views.
Price fromUS$ 286per nightSelect
Not available
House On Chase Creek3 Locust Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, United StatesView on map
1.2 mi from Shelter Island1.2 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the garden and the hotel is set close to Railroad Museum of Long Island.
Price fromUS$ 227per nightSelect
Not available
Harbor Knoll Bed & Breakfast424 4Th Street, Greenport, United States, NY 11944View on map
2.5 mi from Shelter Island2.5 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the sea and the hotel is set close to Sylvester Manor Educational Farm.
Price fromUS$ 400per nightSelect
Not available
The Menhaden Hotel207 Front Street, Greenport, United States, NY 11944View on map
2.6 mi from Shelter Island2.6 mi from City Center
The luxury hotel is a good starting point to Greenport' sights including Kontokosta Winery and Congregation Tifereth Israel.
Price fromUS$ 606per nightSelect
Not available
Historic White Blossom House695 Pine Neck Road, Southold, United States, 11971View on map
5.0 mi from Shelter Island5.0 mi from City Center
Located 20 minutes' drive from Southold city center, this hotel offers a patio and a golf course.
Price fromUS$ 369per nightSelect
Not available
West Neck Guesthouse31 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island Heights, United States, NY 11965View on map
1.0 mi from Shelter Island1.0 mi from City Center
A few meters away you can enjoy Shelter Island Craft Brewery.
Price fromUS$ 245per nightSelect
Not available
The Gallery439 Main Street, Greenport, United States, NY 11944View on map
2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
Located 1 km from the center of the city, the hotel offers a playroom and board games for children.
Price fromUS$ 266per nightSelect
Not available
A Room At The Beach2668 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton, United States, NY 11937View on map
9.2 mi from Shelter Island9.2 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the garden and the hotel is set close to South Fork Natural History Museum.
Price fromUS$ 491per nightSelect
Not available
Charming Lakehouse In Southampton240 Big Fresh Pond Road, Southampton, United States, 11968View on map
11.3 mi from Shelter Island11.3 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the garden and the hotel is set close to Skiff Guide.
Select
Not available
Fordham HouseApartment817 Main Street, Greenport, United StatesView on map
3.2 mi from Shelter Island3.2 mi from City Center
Featuring free self parking and a picnic area, this property is situated a short distance from Greenport Farmers' Market.
Select
Not available
Hamptons House Of Gardens534 North Magee Street , Southampton, United States, 11968View on map
11.7 mi from Shelter Island11.7 mi from City Center
The hotel has an outdoor pool and lies close to Conscience Point Historic Site which is worth visiting.
Select
Not available
English Country CottageVilla8485 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939View on map
4.1 mi from Shelter Island4.1 mi from City Center
Placed a 10-minute walk from East Marion's city centre, the villa features a sunbathing terrace, a library and a golf course.
Price fromUS$ 450per nightSelect
Not available
Victorian Seasons StirlingVilla857 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939View on map
3.2 mi from Shelter Island3.2 mi from City Center
Situated in East Marion next to Greenport Fire, this property features cots, playpens and board games for families with children.
Price fromUS$ 1 250per nightSelect
Not available
French Country CottageVilla8485 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939View on map
4.0 mi from Shelter Island4.0 mi from City Center
This property is 3.3 km from Camera Obscura and welcomes its guests to enjoy mini golf and fishing.
Price fromUS$ 430per nightSelect
Not available
Villa Florencia - Luxuriant 11 Bedroom VillaVillaHalsey Ln, Bridgehampton, United States, 11932View on map
9.6 mi from Shelter Island9.6 mi from City Center
Situated 32 km from Montauk Park in Bridgehampton, this venue features a private pool.
Price fromUS$ 5 722per nightSelect
Not available
Villa Victoria - Cozy Hamptons VillaVilla81 Bridgefield Rd, Bridgehampton, United States, 11932View on map
9.2 mi from Shelter Island9.2 mi from City Center
This 4-bedroom property includes a private swimming pool, and lies in proximity to South Fork Natural History Museum.
Select
Not available
Home In Long Island Wine Country - Walk To Beach!VillaCutchogue, NY, 11935, Cutchogue, United States, 11935View on map
7.2 mi from Shelter Island7.2 mi from City Center
Our Lady of Ostrabama Roman Catholic Church is 2.5 miles from this villa that offers 3 bedrooms along with a fully-fitted kitchen.
Select
Not available
Southampton House W/Yard & Pool, Near Harbor!VillaSouthampton, NY, 11968, Southampton, United States, 11968View on map
9.8 mi from Shelter Island9.8 mi from City Center
This is a 3-bedroom villa, set in proximity to Seven Ponds Orchard.
Select
Not available
East Marion Home Walk To Beach-3 Mi To Greenport!VillaEast Marion, Ny, 11939, East Marion, United States, 11939View on map
4.3 mi from Shelter Island4.3 mi from City Center
Offering a fully equipped kitchen complete with a microwave, a dishwasher and a refrigerator, this villa is located close to Bible Baptist Church.
Price fromUS$ 383per nightSelect
Not available
Luxe East Hampton Family Home W/ Pool + Grill!VillaEast Hampton, NY, 11937, East Hampton, United States, 11937View on map
7.9 mi from Shelter Island7.9 mi from City Center
Offering a full kitchen equipped with a microwave, a dishwasher and a washing machine, this villa is set near Fairview Farm.
Select
Not available
Villa VajraHotel94 Beckeys Path, East Hampton, United States, 11932View on map
8.4 mi from Shelter Island8.4 mi from City Center
Atlantic Avenue Beach is 16 km from this villa that offers 5 bedrooms along with a full kitchen.
Price fromUS$ 1 380per nightSelect
Not available
Downtown Greenport Apt W/Porch Near Shelter IslandApartment, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
Placed 1.6 miles from Our Lady of the Isle Church, the property consists of 1 bedrooms, 1 bathrooms and a kitchen.
Price fromUS$ 285per nightSelect
Not available
Converted Greenport Schoolhouse, 1 Mi To TownVillaGreenport, NY, 11944, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
3.5 mi from Shelter Island3.5 mi from City Center
This is a 3-bedroom villa, set in proximity to Gardiner's Bay Country Club.
Price fromUS$ 465per nightSelect
Not available
Hamptons Home W/Solar-Heated Pool-Walk To Beach!VillaSag Harbor, NY, 11963, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963View on map
5.9 mi from Shelter Island5.9 mi from City Center
Offering a fully equipped kitchen equipped with a microwave, a dishwasher and a fridge, this villa is set near Bay Street Theatre.
Select
Not available
Sag Harbor Home W/ Deck, Dock & Private Beach!VillaSag Harbor, NY, 11963, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963View on map
5.5 mi from Shelter Island5.5 mi from City Center
Offering a fully-fitted kitchen equipped with a microwave, a fridge and a cooktop, this villa is set near Old Whalers Church of Sag.
Select
Not available
Hamptons Home W/ Heated Pool - Walk To Beach!VillaEast Hampton, NY, 11937, East Hampton, United States, 11937View on map
6.5 mi from Shelter Island6.5 mi from City Center
Tulla Booth Gallery is 4.7 miles from this villa that offers 4 bedrooms along with a fully-fitted kitchen.
Select
Not available
East Hampton Home W/Pool & Fire Pit - Near VillageVillaEast Hampton, NY, 11937, East Hampton, United States, 11937View on map
7.6 mi from Shelter Island7.6 mi from City Center
Merrill Lake Sanctuary is 3.1 miles from this villa that offers 3 bedrooms along with a fully-fitted kitchen.
Select
Not available
Greenport Home W/Furnished Patio - Walk Downtown!Villa, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
Price fromUS$ 328per nightSelect
Not available
Villa GallyVilla40 Hedges Banks Dr, East Hampton, Ny 11937, East Hampton, United States, NY 11937View on map
6.7 mi from Shelter Island6.7 mi from City Center
Price fromUS$ 5 134per nightSelect
Not available
Villa Lona Gorgeous Villa With Fantastic PoolApartment5 White Pine Rd, East Hampton, United States, 11937View on map
7.2 mi from Shelter Island7.2 mi from City Center
Situated 7 km from Pantigo Road Historic District in East Hampton, this venue features an indoor pool.
Price fromUS$ 1 294per nightSelect
Not available
Sag Harbor House W/ 2 Decks - Walk To Beach!VillaSag Harbor, Ny, 11963, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963View on map
5.7 mi from Shelter Island5.7 mi from City Center
Offering a full kitchen equipped with a microwave oven, a dishwasher and a refrigerator, this villa is set near Urban Zen.
Price fromUS$ 1 347per nightSelect
Not available
Summer Retreat Minutes From The Beach And In Wine Country !!!Villa55 Shepard Drive, Southold, United States, NY 11971View on map
5.2 mi from Shelter Island5.2 mi from City Center
Select
Not available
Southold Cottage W/Deck+Grill - Walk To BeachVillaSouthold, Ny, 11971, Southold, United States, 11971View on map
5.6 mi from Shelter Island5.6 mi from City Center
Offering a fully-fitted kitchen equipped with a microwave and a refrigerator, this villa is set near McCabe's Beach.
Select
Not available
Remodeled Greenport Apartment By Greenport HarborApartmentGreenport, Ny, 11944, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
Located in Greenport, and a short stroll from Greenport Harbor Brewing Company, this venue includes a fully furnished kitchen with a microwave and a dishwasher, as well as 1 bathrooms.
Price fromUS$ 288per nightSelect
Not available
Luxury East Hampton Home W/Private Saltwater Pool!VillaEast Hampton, Ny, 11937, East Hampton, United States, 11937View on map
8.2 mi from Shelter Island8.2 mi from City Center
Offering a full kitchen equipped with a microwave oven, a dishwasher and a fridge, this villa is set near Guild Hall of East Hampton.
Price fromUS$ 942per nightSelect
Not available
Greenport Village Vacationer'S DelightVilla, Greenport, United States, 11944View on map
2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
This is a 3-bedroom villa, set in proximity to Camera Obscura.
Select
Not available
The Parkside Retreat In NoyacVilla, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963View on map
5.4 mi from Shelter Island5.4 mi from City Center
Offering a fully equipped kitchen complete with a dishwasher, a refrigerator and a washing machine, this villa is located close to Ark Project Inc.
Select
Not available
Lower Seven Ponds HavenVilla, Water Mill, United States, 11976View on map
10.9 mi from Shelter Island10.9 mi from City Center
Featuring a patio along with 3 bedrooms, this villa is set 3.6 km from Southampton History Museum.
Select
Not available
Villa KeylimeVilla3, Wilson Place, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963View on map
5.9 mi from Shelter Island5.9 mi from City Center
Offering a kitchen equipped with a microwave oven, a dishwasher and a fridge, this villa is set near Out of the Closet.
Price fromUS$ 1 278per nightSelect
Not available
Villa MachisVilla2765 Deerfield Rd, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963View on map
6.3 mi from Shelter Island6.3 mi from City Center
Conscience Point Historic Site is 7 km from this villa that offers 5 bedrooms along with a kitchen.
Price fromUS$ 2 088per nightSelect
Not available
Villa Red HutVilla832 Millstone Road, Water Mill, United States, 11976View on map
6.9 mi from Shelter Island6.9 mi from City Center
Offering a fully equipped kitchen complete with a microwave oven, a dishwasher and a refrigerator, this villa is located close to The Hampton Classic.
Price fromUS$ 2 156per nightSelect
Not available
Villa Charlotte - Elegant 7 BedroomVilla309 Old Sag Harbor Road, Southampton, United States, 11968View on map
6.6 mi from Shelter Island6.6 mi from City Center
Offering a kitchen equipped with a microwave oven, coffee/tea making facilities and an oven, this villa is set near Children's Museum of The East End.
Select
Not available
Villa Bridgehampton VillageVilla13 Ludlow Green, East Hampton, United States, 11932View on map
9.1 mi from Shelter Island9.1 mi from City Center
This is a 5-bedroom villa, set in proximity to Nancy + Co..
Select
Not available
Villa Luminous W Heated PoolApartment8 2Nd Ave, East Hampton, United States, 11937View on map
9.5 mi from Shelter Island9.5 mi from City Center
Located 7 km from Indian Wells, this villa features a heated pool and is equipped with a kitchen.
Price fromUS$ 1 709per nightSelect
Not available
Villa El SuenoVilla28 Clamshell Ave, East Hampton, United States, 11937View on map
7.8 mi from Shelter Island7.8 mi from City Center
This is a 4-bedroom villa, set in proximity to Cedar Point County Park.
Price fromUS$ 3 450per nightSelect
Not available
Villa Nostro PalazzoVilla75 S Breeze Dr, East Hampton, United States, NY 11937View on map
8.0 mi from Shelter Island8.0 mi from City Center
Situated a 20-minute drive to North Main Street Historic District, this villa features a balcony and a terrace.
Price fromUS$ 2 380per nightSelect
Not available

Filtering results

Please wait...

77 hotels found

FAQs about hotels in Shelter Island

We hope that the answers to these questions will help you plan your trip

Which hotels are located near the airport in Shelter Island?
Travelers who stayed in Shelter Island near Montauk, NY (MTP) airport have left good reviews about Sun And Sound Montauk and Kenny'S Tipperary Inn.