Popular filters
Sort by
Legend
Legend
  • Hotels on page
  •  
  • Other hotels
  • Airports
  • Underground stations
  • Train stations
  • Parks
  • Tourist attractions
  • Museums
  • Convention centers
  • Stadiums
  • Food and meals
  • General

Hover above the icons to see hotel photo and details.

Click the hotel to go to the main hotel page.

Check rooms and rates
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room
SOLD OUT, the hotel has no available rooms from NaN to NaN( nights)

Best Shelter Island NY hotels, motels and accommodations of 2019

We offer 5 hotels in Shelter Island
Get Prices
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room
Sort by
  • Sort by:
  • Popularityfrom low to highfrom high to low
  • Pricefrom low to highfrom high to low
  • Guest ratingfrom low to highfrom high to low
Legend
Legend
  • Hotels on page
  •  
  • Other hotels
  • Airports
  • Underground stations
  • Train stations
  • Parks
  • Tourist attractions
  • Museums
  • Convention centers
  • Stadiums
  • Food and meals
  • General

Hover above the icons to see hotel photo and details.

Click the hotel to go to the main hotel page.

The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11964, show map
Superbbased on 1 review
9.2
  • Free Wi-Fi

    Free Wi-Fi in public areas

  • Parking

    On-site car park

  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services
  • Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    Restaurant

  • Swimming pool

    Seasonal outdoor pool

FromUS$351Select Hotel
Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11965, show map
Fabulousbased on 21 reviews
7.6
  • Internet

    Free internet access

  • Parking
  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services

    24-hour reception

  • Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    Restaurant

  • TV

    Flat-screen TV

FromUS$595Select Hotel
Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island7 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11965, show map
Exclusivebased on 2 reviews
9.8
  • Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    On-site car park

  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services
  • Food/ Drinks

    Restaurant buffet

  • Spa and relaxation

    Massage

FromUS$406Select Hotel
Sunshine Bungalow Shelter Island Retreat - 2Bedrooms, 3Beds6 Sunshine Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11964, show map
  • Wi-Fi
  • Free parking
  • Kitchen facilities
  • Air conditioning
  • TV

    Flat-screen TV

  • Food/ Drinks

    Outdoor dining area

Select Hotel
Waterfront Estate Shelter Island Holiday home74A North Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, United States, NY 11964, show map
  • Wi-Fi
  • Free parking
  • Kitchen facilities

    Dryer

    Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

  • Air conditioning
  • TV

    Flat-screen TV

  • Sports activities

    Hiking

    Fishing

Select Hotel
Hotels near Shelter Island
The Blue Inn At North Fork East Marion7850 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939, show map
Fabulousbased on 9 reviews
8.0
3.9 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    On-site car park

  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services
  • Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    Outdoor dining area

    Restaurant

  • Swimming pool

    Seasonal outdoor pool

FromUS$205Select Hotel
The Greenporter Hotel326 Front Street, Greenport, United States, 11944, show map
Superbbased on 3 reviews
8.8
2.7 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
Select Hotel
The Stirling House B&B Greenport104 Bay Avenue, Greenport, United States, 11944, show map
2.7 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    Off-site car park

  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services
  • Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    Outdoor dining area

    Snack bar

  • TV

    Flat-screen TV

FromUS$291Select Hotel
Quintessentials Bed And Breakfast And Spa East Marion8985 Main Road, P.O. Box 574, East Marion, United States, 11939, show map
4.0 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    On-site car park

  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services
  • Food/ Drinks

    Outdoor dining area

    Snack bar

  • Shuttle

    Paid airport shuttle

FromUS$332Select Hotel
Townsend Manor Inn Greenport714 Main Street, Greenport, United States, 11944, show map
Very goodbased on 6 reviews
7.4
3.1 mi from Shelter Island
  • Free Wi-Fi

    Free Wi-Fi in public areas

  • Free parking
  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services
  • Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    Restaurant

    Snack bar

  • Swimming pool

    Outdoor swimming pool

FromUS$165Select Hotel
Baron'S Cove Hotel Sag Harbor31 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963, show map
5.1 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    On-site car park

  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services

    24-hour reception

  • Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    Restaurant

  • Fitness/ Gym

    Fitness centre

FromUS$293Select Hotel
Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast East Marion8900 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939, show map
Exclusivebased on 22 reviews
9.4
4.1 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    On-site car park

  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services
  • Food/ Drinks

    Outdoor dining area

    Restaurant buffet

    Picnic area/ Tables

  • Shuttle

    Paid shuttle service

FromUS$350Select Hotel
Cliffside Resort Condominiums - Greenport61475 Route 48, Greenport, United States, 11944, show map
3.5 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    On-site car park

  • Kitchen facilities

    Kitchen

  • Air conditioning
  • Laundry
  • Private beach
FromUS$259Select Hotel
Orient Inn East Marion25500 Main Road, East Marion, United States, show map
5.9 mi from Shelter Island
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    Car park

  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services
  • TV

    Flat-screen TV

  • Breakfast
FromUS$333Select Hotel
Fordham House Apartment Greenport817 Main Street, Greenport, United States, show map
3.2 mi from Shelter Island
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    Car park

  • Kitchen facilities
  • Air conditioning
  • Breakfast
Select Hotel
The Harborfront Inn Greenport209 Front Street, Greenport, United States, 11944, show map
2.6 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
  • Free parking
  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services

    24-hour reception

  • Fitness/ Gym

    Fitness centre

  • Swimming pool

    Seasonal outdoor pool

FromUS$235Select Hotel
American Beech Hotel Greenport300 Main Street, Greenport, United States, show map
2.7 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
  • Parking
  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour services
  • Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    Restaurant

    Snack bar

  • Spa and relaxation

    Massage

FromUS$302Select Hotel
English Country Cottage East Marion8485 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939, show map
4.1 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    Off-site car park

  • Kitchen facilities

    Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

  • Air conditioning
  • TV

    Flat-screen TV

  • Check-in/ Check-out

    Express check-in/ -out

    VIP check-in/ -out

Select Hotel
Victorian Seasons Stirling Holiday home East Marion857 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939, show map
3.2 mi from Shelter Island
  • Wi-Fi
  • Parking

    Off-site car park

  • Kitchen facilities

    Dryer

    Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

  • Air conditioning
  • TV

    Flat-screen TV

  • Laundry
FromUS$1 250Select Hotel
French Country Cottage East Marion8485 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939, show map
4.0 mi from Shelter Island
  • Free Wi-Fi

    Free Wi-Fi in rooms

  • Free parking
  • Kitchen facilities

    Dryer

    Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

  • Air conditioning
  • TV

    Flat-screen TV

  • Laundry
FromUS$475Select Hotel

Filtering results

Please wait...

28 hotels found