For those looking to be close to Dering Harbor Marina, The Chequit will put you within a 5-minute walk from the city center where you can find a range of sights. To stay near Shelter Island Heights's famous attractions, consider The Chequit, which is near Our Lady of the Isle Church and offers rooms at 288US$ per an one-night stay.
| 🏨 Hotels in Shelter Island Heights | 75 |
| 👛 Lowest price | 91 USD |
| ✍️ Hotels Reviews | 309 |
23Sept2023Saturday
24Sept2023Sunday
1-75 out of 75
Sort by:
high popularity
- Price: low to high
- Price: high to low
- Guest rating: high to low
- Popularity: high to low
-
The hotel has
- Free Wi-Fi in public areas
-
The hotel has
- Bar/ Lounge area
- Restaurant
- Snack bar
- Picnic area/ Tables
View on map1500 yd from City Center1800 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
The 4-star Shelter Island House Shelter Island Heights is located around 10 minutes by foot from Crescent Beach and comprises 11 rooms with modern comforts.
From
US$ 282
/night
House On Chase Creek Bed & Breakfast Shelter Island HeightsBed & Breakfast
-
The bed & breakfast has
- 24-hour reception
View on map400 yd from City Center600 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation is about a 25-minute walk away and Greenport Antique Carousel can be reached within 10 minutes by car.
8.6
Great88 reviews
10
From
US$ 218
/night
The ChequitInn
View on map100 yd from City Center700 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
Featuring 33 rooms with views of the sea, the Chequit Shelter Island Heights is set approximately 1.4 miles from Shelter Island.
8.8
Great1515 reviews
10
From
US$ 621
/night
West Neck GuesthouseBed & Breakfast
Situated only 0.7 miles from Crescent Beach, the 2-star West Neck Guesthouse offers 6 guest rooms.
From
US$ 357
/night
Similar properties near Shelter Island Heights
Baron'S CoveHotel
View on map6.5 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.5 mi from City Center
Set just walking distance from Custom House Museum, the 4-star luxury Baron'S Cove Sag Harbor offers a seasonal outdoor pool together with fitness classes and spa therapy for guest enjoyment.
8.6
Great3131 reviews
10
From
US$ 219
/night
American Beech HotelHotel
View on map1.4 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.4 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing city and the 4-star American Beech is set less than a 6-minute stroll from Greenport Antique Carousel.
8.6
Great2828 reviews
10
From
US$ 1 223
/night
Sound View GreenportHotel
View on map2.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.3 mi from City Center
The Sound View Greenport overlooks the ocean and boasts a location in a beach area.
8.4
Great1414 reviews
10
From
US$ 240
/night
The Harbor Front InnHotel
View on map1.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.3 mi from City Center
Railroad Museum of Long Island is a 5-minute walk away and Kontokosta Winery can be reached within 10 minutes by car.
9.0
Perfect2626 reviews
10
From
US$ 329
/night
Greenporter HotelHotel
View on map1.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.3 mi from City Center
The 3-star Greenporter Greenport is set 10 minutes' drive from Shelter Island and 700 feet from Fireboat Firefighter Museum.
8.6
Great1818 reviews
10
From
US$ 176
/night
The Menhaden HotelHotel
View on map1.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.3 mi from City Center
Positioned within 900 feet of Railroad Museum of Long Island, the Menhaden Greenport has 15 rooms, the à la carte restaurant serving the Mediterranean cuisine, all at guest's disposal.
8.6
Great44 reviews
10
From
US$ 499
/night
The Pridwin HotelHotel
View on map1.4 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.4 mi from City Center
Featuring a heated swimming pool and 33 rooms, the Pridwin is within 2.3 miles of Greenport Antique Carousel.
8.8
Great2222 reviews
10
From
US$ 334
/night
Harbor Knoll Bed And BreakfastBed & Breakfast
View on map1.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.1 mi from City Center
Shelter Island is set within a 10-minute drive of the 3-star Harbor Knoll Bed And Breakfast Greenport.
8.0
Great1010 reviews
10
From
US$ 357
/night
The Stirling House Waterfront Inn GreenportBed & Breakfast
View on map1.4 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.4 mi from City Center
Placed 53 miles from Long Island MacArthur airport, the 4-star Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport features a restaurant and baggage storage as well as bicycles for rent.
8.8
Great2424 reviews
10
From
US$ 317
/night
Southold Beach MotelMotel
View on map3.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.1 mi from City Center
Founders Landing Park is about 1.9 miles away and Custer Institute & Observatory can be reached within 10 minutes by car.
From
US$ 155
/night
View on map7.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights7.3 mi from City Center
Old Town Arts And Crafts Guild is around 10 minutes' drive from the Home In Long Island Wine Country - Walk To Beach! Cutchogue, while Catapano Dairy Farm is 2.8 miles away.
From
US$ 271
/night
Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter IslandBed & Breakfast
View on map1400 yd from Shelter Island Heights1400 yd from City Center1700 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
Founders Landing Park is approximately 2.9 miles from the 4-star Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island and Dering Harbor Marina is about a 20-minute stroll away.
8.8
Great2121 reviews
10
From
US$ 873
/night
Sunset BeachHotel
View on map1600 yd from Shelter Island Heights1600 yd from City Center1.1 mi from Dering Harbor Marina
Greenport Antique Carousel is within a 10-minute drive of the Sunset Beach, while Fireboat Firefighter Museum is 10 minutes' drive away.
7.8
Very good2626 reviews
10
From
US$ 596
/night
A Walk In The Woods Bed And BreakfastBed & Breakfast
View on map3.8 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.8 mi from City Center
Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum is within 4 miles of the 3-star Walk In The Woods and Southold Bay Oysters is just 0.9 miles away.
8.8
Great2020 reviews
10
From
US$ 310
/night
View on map3.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.3 mi from City Center
Camera Obscura and East Marion are respectively 2.3 miles and 700 feet from the charming Home Walk To Beach-3 Mi To Greenport!.
From
US$ 265
/night
The Cliffside Resort CondominiumsApartment
View on map2.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.1 mi from City Center
About 25 minutes' stroll from Greenport Antique Carousel, the Cliffside Resort Condominiums offers yoga classes and barbeque grills plus a seasonal outdoor swimming pool.
7.6
Very good44 reviews
10
From
US$ 560
/night
View on map2.6 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.6 mi from City Center
While staying at the 4-star Shoals Suites & Slips you are invited to discover Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum, set about 2.3 miles away, or Fireboat Firefighter Museum, which is 2.6 miles away.
7.8
Very good44 reviews
10
From
US$ 595
/night
View on map4.5 mi from Shelter Island Heights4.5 mi from City Center
Southold Bay Oysters is 1.8 miles from the 2-star Historic White Blossom House, while Southold Bay is 20 minutes' stroll away.
From
US$ 500
/night
Arbor View House Bed And BreakfastBed & Breakfast
View on map3.0 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.0 mi from City Center
The smoke free Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast East Marion is set 0.6 miles from Lavender By the Bay and within 2.2 miles of Greenport Antique Carousel.
8.6
Great3434 reviews
10
From
US$ 291
/night
Cowgirl PalaceHomestay
View on map8.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights8.3 mi from City Center
The homestay comes with an outdoor swimming pool and is set 2 miles from ARF - Animal Rescue Fund of the Hamptons.
From
US$ 400
/night
Sag Harbor BeautyVilla
View on map6.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.1 mi from City Center
Located 1 miles from Sag Harbor, this villa offers a patio, a private beach area and a garden together with 3 bathrooms.
From
US$ 1 417
/night
View on map2.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.1 mi from City Center
From
US$ 599
/night
View on map1.5 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.5 mi from City Center
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm and Fireboat Firefighter Museum are located 2.6 miles and 0.7 miles from the Bright 2Nd-Floor Apt - Half Mi To Greenport Harbor! Greenport respectively.
From
US$ 377
/night
From
US$ 450
/night
View on map1.5 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.5 mi from City Center
The Quaint Dt Greenport Apt - 2 Mi To Shelter Island! is located in a downtown area approximately 10 minutes' stroll from Greenport.
From
US$ 245
/night
View on map7.8 mi from Shelter Island Heights7.8 mi from City Center
Located 1 miles from path continues, this villa offers a cable flat-screen and a flat screen TV together with 4 bathrooms.
From
US$ 1 015
/night
View on map6.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.3 mi from City Center
Located 1 miles from Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge, the villa features a cable flat-screen and a flat screen TV.
From
US$ 2 044
/night
View on map1.5 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.5 mi from City Center
While staying at the charming Home With Furnished Patio, Walk Downtown! Greenport you are invited to discover Lavender By the Bay, set 1.8 miles away, or Railroad Museum of Long Island, which is about 5 minutes' stroll away.
From
US$ 424
/night
View on map7.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights7.3 mi from City Center
Located about 1 miles from Schiavoni's Market Inc, the villa offers accommodation for 8 guests.
From
US$ 2 153
/night
View on map8.2 mi from Shelter Island Heights8.2 mi from City Center
Set within walking distance of Ark Project Inc, this villa includes 7 bedrooms and an equipped kitchen for guests' convenience.
From
US$ 4 470
/night
View on map3.9 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.9 mi from City Center
Being within 2.8 miles of Greenport, this villa features a shared lounge.
Villa VajraVilla
View on map9.6 mi from Shelter Island Heights9.6 mi from City Center
Featuring a swimming pool, the Villa Vajra East Hampton lies just 900 feet from Children's Museum of the East End.
From
US$ 2 153
/night
View on map1.4 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.4 mi from City Center
Southold Bay Oysters is within 3.9 miles of the Village Vacationer'S Delight Greenport, while Camera Obscura is about a 10-minute walk away.
From
US$ 460
/night
View on map6.5 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.5 mi from City Center
Trout Pond Park is also set in proximity to the Parkside Retreat In Noyac Sag Harbor.
From
US$ 295
/night
View on map2.5 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.5 mi from City Center
From
US$ 1 219
/night
From
US$ 803
/night
View on map3.6 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.6 mi from City Center
View on map8.0 mi from Shelter Island Heights8.0 mi from City Center
From
US$ 4 835
/night
From
US$ 413
/night
View on map6.6 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.6 mi from City Center
From
US$ 990
/night
View on map6.4 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.4 mi from City Center
Sag Harbor Marine Park is 2.2 miles from this villa that offers 4 bedrooms along with a fully-fitted kitchen.
From
US$ 969
/night
From
US$ 359
/night
View on map4.7 mi from Shelter Island Heights4.7 mi from City Center
Being within 2.9 miles of Bedell Cellars, this villa features a sunny patio.
From
US$ 702
/night
View on map6.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.3 mi from City Center
View on map6.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.1 mi from City Center
From
US$ 383
/night
View on map3.6 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.6 mi from City Center
View on map4.2 mi from Shelter Island Heights4.2 mi from City Center
Catapano Dairy Farm is within 1.6 miles of the Classic Southold Country Charmer, while Southold Indian Museum is about a 10-minute walk away.
From
US$ 91
/night
From
US$ 363
/night
View on map1.6 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.6 mi from City Center
From
US$ 406
/night
From
US$ 188
/night
From
US$ 4 807
/night
From
US$ 5 837
/night
From
US$ 430
/night
Come Sail AwayVilla
View on map4.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights4.1 mi from City Center
Situated 4.3 miles from Wickham's Fruit Farm, the villa offers windsurfing, cycling and fisheries.
From
US$ 654
/night
From
US$ 2 760
/night
View on map2.6 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.6 mi from City Center
From
US$ 678
/night
View on map6.9 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.9 mi from City Center
The Hampton Classic is 4 miles from this villa that offers 3 bedrooms along with an equipped kitchenette area.
From
US$ 846
/night
Saved
Save
Filtering results
Please wait...
75 hotels found
FAQs about hotels in Shelter Island Heights
We hope that the answers to these questions will help you plan your trip
What are the best romantic hotels in Shelter Island Heights?
According to Booked.net travel data, there are 5 deals for couples. For more romantic deals go here.
What are the top pet-friendly hotels in Shelter Island Heights?
According to Booked.net travel data, there are 3 hotels that welcome pets. Alternatively, book The Chequit rated 8.0/10 for 496US$ per night. It's located 5 minutes` walk from the city center and offers a golf course, concierge service and housekeeping service on site. See more pet-friendly accommodations here.
Which Shelter Island Heights hotels are the best to stay at?
Also, you may book The Chequit (rating: 8.0/10), a fantastic hotel with a golf course, concierge service and housekeeping service. It costs about 496US$ per night.
What is the average cost of a hotel room in Shelter Island Heights?
According to Booked.net travel data, the average prices for Shelter Island Heights properties are:
A 4-star hotel room costs 512US$ per night. You may check Shelter Island House with an outdoor swimming pool, a picnic area and cycling.