Check rooms and rates
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Sorry, we don't recognize this name.Enter a destination to start the search
We can’t find that destination
Try to change your search
The Internet connection seems to be slow. It may take a few more seconds to load the page. Thank you for your patience.
×
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Sorry, we don't recognize this name.Enter a destination to start the search
We can’t find that destination
Try to change your search
The Internet connection seems to be slow. It may take a few more seconds to load the page. Thank you for your patience.
×
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room
Check rooms and rates
exclusive online offers!
Destination
Sorry, we don't recognize this name.Enter a destination to start the search
We can’t find that destination
Try to change your search
The Internet connection seems to be slow. It may take a few more seconds to load the page. Thank you for your patience.
×
Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests
2Guests1room

3-star hotels in Shelter Island, New York

Search the best hotels and places to stay in Shelter Island

View map
Filter by
Other filters
Sort by
  • Sort by
  • Pricefrom low to highfrom high to low
  • Popularityfrom low to highfrom high to low
  • Guest ratingfrom low to highfrom high to low
Applied filters
Stars:   ×
  • The hotel has
    • Bar/ Lounge area
    • Restaurant
  • The hotel has
    • Flat-screen TV
View on map1.5 mi from City Center100 yd from City Center
Set within easy reach of Mashomack Preserve, the venue features a beachfront restaurant serving meals of French cuisine.
7.4
Very good22 reviews
From   US$ 596 /nightSelect
Not available
Similar properties near Shelter Island
  • The hotel has
    • Valet parking
  • The hotel has
    • 24-hour security
View on map2.7 mi from Shelter Island2.7 mi from City Center
Within easy reach of Kontokosta Winery, this hotel comprises 30 rooms with en suite bathrooms.
8.6
Great4 reviews
From   US$ 272 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map13.4 mi from Shelter Island13.4 mi from City Center
This hotel features rooms with pool views, while a convenient location provides easy access to Shinnecock Museuem and Cultural Center.
6.6
Nice27 reviews
From   US$ 294 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map11.3 mi from Shelter Island11.3 mi from City Center
At this venue, boasting a location in a resort area, guests can enjoy a sundeck, barbeque grills and tennis courts, or explore Egypt Lane Historic District nearby.
7.8
Very good11 reviews
From   US$ 341 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map10.9 mi from Shelter Island10.9 mi from City Center
Offering convenient proximity to The Jewish Center of the Hamptons, the hotel is also close to North Main Street Historic District.
7.6
Very good3 reviews
From   US$ 250 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.6 mi from Shelter Island2.6 mi from City Center
Set near Kontokosta Winery, this central venue is 10 minutes' walk of the city center.
7.8
Very good4 reviews
From   US$ 413 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map3.9 mi from Shelter Island3.9 mi from City Center
Just off Camera Obscura, this hotel offers a beautiful location and includes an indoor restaurant.
7.8
Very good11 reviews
From   US$ 183 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map4.1 mi from Shelter Island4.1 mi from City Center
At this venue, boasting a location in a beach area, guests can enjoy a shared lounge, a library and a golf course, or explore The Old Field Vineyards nearby.
6.8
Nice12 reviews
From   US$ 306 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map1.9 mi from Shelter Island1.9 mi from City Center
Featuring a private pool and views of the bay, the property offers guests to enjoy American meals and take advantage of its location in Shelter Island.
8.0
Great4 reviews
From   US$ 679 /nightSelect
Not available
Heron SuitesResort
View on map3.5 mi from Shelter Island3.5 mi from City Center
This hotel offers the coffee bar and 20 rooms together with convenient location close to One Woman Wines & Vineyards.
8.0
Great17 reviews
From   US$ 255 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map3.6 mi from Shelter Island3.6 mi from City Center
Located just 2.6 km from Fireboat Firefighter Museum, this hotel features a sunbathing terrace, a shared lounge and a golf course for guests' convenience.
From   US$ 407 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map15.0 mi from Shelter Island15.0 mi from City Center
Conveniently located close to Skiff Guide, this hotel in Hampton Bays features an outdoor seasonal pool and barbeque grills.
6.8
Nice2 reviews
From   US$ 158 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map8.9 mi from Shelter Island8.9 mi from City Center
The hotel is located in the beach area of East Hampton, not far away from Pollock-Krasner House and Study Center, overlooking the garden.
From   US$ 779 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map12.5 mi from Shelter Island12.5 mi from City Center
Located close to Agawam Park, the hotel has 13 rooms, and boasts access to a train station.
6.0
Guest rating9 reviews
From   US$ 662 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.8 mi from Shelter Island2.8 mi from City Center
Located 1 km from the center of the city, the hotel offers a playroom and board games for children.
From   US$ 266 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map2.5 mi from Shelter Island2.5 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the sea and the hotel is set close to Sylvester Manor Educational Farm.
From   US$ 400 /nightSelect
Not available
Hamlet InnHotel
View on map13.9 mi from Shelter Island13.9 mi from City Center
Offering a prime location close to Shinnecock Museuem and Cultural Center, this hotel holds in total 13 rooms boasting barbeque grills and a golf course onsite.
7.6
Very good24 reviews
From   US$ 397 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map3.6 mi from Shelter Island3.6 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the mountain and the hotel is set close to Custer Institute & Observatory.
From   US$ 270 /nightSelect
Not available
View on map11.3 mi from Shelter Island11.3 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the garden and the hotel is set close to Skiff Guide.
Select
Not available
View on map11.2 mi from Shelter Island11.2 mi from City Center
The boutique hotel is located in a busy area with quick access to Indian Wells.
Select
Not available
View on map11.7 mi from Shelter Island11.7 mi from City Center
A few meters away you can enjoy Pelletreau Silver Shop.
Select
Not available
View on map11.7 mi from Shelter Island11.7 mi from City Center
The hotel has an outdoor pool and lies close to Conscience Point Historic Site which is worth visiting.
Select
Not available
View on map9.2 mi from Shelter Island9.2 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the garden and the hotel is set close to South Fork Natural History Museum.
From   US$ 491 /nightSelect
Not available

Filtering results

Please wait...

23 hotels found