Best Fire Island NY hotels, motels and accommodations of 2020
Search the best hotels and places to stay in Fire Island
Filter by
Other filters
Sort by
- Sort by
- Pricefrom low to highfrom high to low
- Popularityfrom low to highfrom high to low
- Guest ratingfrom low to highfrom high to low
8 adults
4 bedrooms
4 beds
View on map4.2 mi from City Center
From
US$ 2 011
/night
Similar properties near Fire Island
-
The hotel has
- USD 12 per day
-
The hotel has
- 24-hour reception
- 24-hour business centre
View on map11.6 mi from Fire Island11.6 mi from City Center
There are rooms facing the terrace and the hotel is set close to Blydenburgh Park.
7.4
Very good39 reviews
From
US$ 209
/night
View on map18.0 mi from Fire Island18.0 mi from City Center
Located next to The Atelier at Flowerfield Inc, the venue comprises 12 rooms with harbor views.
7.0
Very good15 reviews
From
US$ 182
/night
View on map14.2 mi from Fire Island14.2 mi from City Center
Guests of this hotel can relax in the cocktail bar or lounge at an indoor swimming pool.
6.6
Nice37 reviews
From
US$ 135
/night
View on map15.3 mi from Fire Island15.3 mi from City Center
This hotel in the suburb district of Commack is situated close to Tanger Outlets and welcomes guests since 1987.
8.2
Great64 reviews
From
US$ 125
/night
View on map11.3 mi from Fire Island11.3 mi from City Center
Boasting setting next to Pennysaver Amphitheater at Bald Hill, this pleasant property offers an outdoor pool onsite as well as cots and video games for children.
8.0
Great95 reviews
From
US$ 173
/night
View on map17.4 mi from Fire Island17.4 mi from City Center
This hotel, featuring 135 non-smoking rooms and a lounge restaurant, is centrally based in the centre of the city.
7.8
Very good9 reviews
From
US$ 209
/night
View on map8.5 mi from Fire Island8.5 mi from City Center
Providing a gym and a fitness centre, the accommodation is situated in Ronkonkoma, and next to a ferry port.
6.0
Guest rating112 reviews
From
US$ 180
/night
View on map8.9 mi from Fire Island8.9 mi from City Center
Guests of the property can relax in the cocktail bar, swim in an outdoor swimming pool, or enjoy barbeque grills and a tennis court close to a train station.
8.2
Great68 reviews
From
US$ 201
/night
View on map12.7 mi from Fire Island12.7 mi from City Center
The hotel was built in 2001 in a shopping area of Hauppauge, and nowadays has 133.
7.4
Very good78 reviews
From
US$ 170
/night
View on map11.6 mi from Fire Island11.6 mi from City Center
The hotel offers easy access to Blydenburgh Park, boasting 120 rooms in the centre of Islandia.
8.2
Great79 reviews
From
US$ 149
/night
View on map19.5 mi from Fire Island19.5 mi from City Center
Located a few steps from Breathe, the hotel features 85 rooms with views over the countryside.
8.0
Great32 reviews
From
US$ 199
/night
View on map10.5 mi from Fire Island10.5 mi from City Center
The hotel offers a private pool, a 24-hour restaurant and a café bar.
7.2
Very good8 reviews
From
US$ 151
/night
View on map11.1 mi from Fire Island11.1 mi from City Center
This hotel offers the bistro bar and 177 rooms together with convenient location close to Pennysaver Amphitheater at Bald Hill.
8.0
Great47 reviews
From
US$ 137
/night
View on map23.3 mi from Fire Island23.3 mi from City Center
At this hotel, you'll find a sports bar, an al fresco restaurant, a spa area, a Jacuzzi and a sauna for pampering guests on site.
8.2
Great16 reviews
From
US$ 162
/night
View on map15.5 mi from Fire Island15.5 mi from City Center
Boasting a snack bar and an outdoor pool, the property is located close to Long Island Museum of American Art and less than 4 km from the centre of Centereach.
7.8
Very good37 reviews
From
US$ 156
/night
View on map12.8 mi from Fire Island12.8 mi from City Center
Nestled next to Wind Watch Golf & Country Club, this pet-friendly venue features an indoor swimming pool and 100 rooms not far from a ferry port.
8.0
Great23 reviews
From
US$ 196
/night
View on map11.7 mi from Fire Island11.7 mi from City Center
This hotel in the suburb district of Bellport is situated close to Medford and welcomes guests since 2010.
8.8
Great33 reviews
From
US$ 133
/night
View on map9.4 mi from Fire Island9.4 mi from City Center
Opened in 2013, close to Citibank Park Stadium, this business property features a gym area and fitness centre.
7.4
Very good7 reviews
From
US$ 188
/night
Bay Shore InnMotel
View on map11.9 mi from Fire Island11.9 mi from City Center
The hotel was built in 1965 in a busy area of Bay Shore, and nowadays has 72.
7.0
Very good2 reviews
From
US$ 99
/night
View on map11.4 mi from Fire Island11.4 mi from City Center
The property dates back to 2007, boasts an industrial-style architecture and has central location close to Pennysaver Amphitheater at Bald Hill.
8.0
Great18 reviews
From
US$ 168
/night
Fire Island HotelHotel
View on map3.7 mi from Fire Island3.7 mi from City Center
Guests can relax in the coffee bar of the hotel that boasts a convenient location in Ocean Bay Park.
From
US$ 259
/night
View on map17.3 mi from Fire Island17.3 mi from City Center
The hotel was built in 1982 in a business area of Copiague, and nowadays has 38.
7.4
Very good11 reviews
From
US$ 126
/night
View on map9.3 mi from Fire Island9.3 mi from City Center
Featuring an outdoor pool, this venue offers 59 rooms right in a shopping area.
6.4
Nice27 reviews
From
US$ 114
/night
View on map9.6 mi from Fire Island9.6 mi from City Center
Located close to Bay Shore Historical Society, the hotel has 41 rooms, and boasts access to a ferry port.
5.2
Guest rating5 reviews
From
US$ 103
/night
View on map9.6 mi from Fire Island9.6 mi from City Center
Guests can relax in the bistro bar of the hotel that boasts a central location in Central Islip.
8.0
Great2 reviews
From
US$ 147
/night
Lakeland InnMotel
View on map8.6 mi from Fire Island8.6 mi from City Center
The historical hotel is a good starting point to Bohemia' sights including Sans Souci County Park and Classic Airport Share-Ride.
8.0
Great2 reviews
From
US$ 104
/night
View on map17.4 mi from Fire Island17.4 mi from City Center
Located close to Mather House Museum, the hotel has 44 rooms, and boasts access to a ferry port.
5.8
Guest rating6 reviews
From
US$ 105
/night
View on map12.9 mi from Fire Island12.9 mi from City Center
A few meters away you can enjoy Charles Toner Park.
South Bay MotelHotel
View on map16.8 mi from Fire Island16.8 mi from City Center
Located a few steps from Sunrise Mall, the hotel features 35 rooms with views over the lake.
From
US$ 122
/night
View on map10.2 mi from Fire Island10.2 mi from City Center
Rooms overlooking the city are offered in this hotel that boasts a perfect setting, while onsite there is an indoor pool.
From
US$ 181
/night
Smithtown InnHotel
View on map15.3 mi from Fire Island15.3 mi from City Center
This industrial-style hotel is set at a short distance to Commack Public Library.
View on map22.2 mi from Fire Island22.2 mi from City Center
Thanks to the hotel's convenient location, guests here can admire views of the terrace or spend their time discovering the business area.
From
US$ 145
/night
Whitman Motor LodgeLodge
View on map20.7 mi from Fire Island20.7 mi from City Center
This well-equipped villa offers accommodation with balcony, placed 32 km from Parks Garage.
From
US$ 115
/night
View on map4.8 mi from Fire Island4.8 mi from City Center
This art deco-style hotel is set at a short distance to The Sunken Forest.
From
US$ 430
/night
112 MotelHotel
View on map10.4 mi from Fire Island10.4 mi from City Center
A few meters away you can enjoy Medford Athletic Complex.
From
US$ 254
/night
View on map14.0 mi from Fire Island14.0 mi from City Center
Set within easy reach of Neguntatogue Park, the venue features a lounge restaurant serving meals of local cuisine.
From
US$ 95
/night
Clegg'S HotelHotel
View on map4.8 mi from Fire Island4.8 mi from City Center
The central hotel in Ocean Beach overlooks the sea, and offers easy access to a ferry port and 15 rooms.
8.0
Great2 reviews
From
US$ 269
/night
The Fox And Owl InnBed & Breakfast
View on map19.0 mi from Fire Island19.0 mi from City Center
Near the hotel, there is a port and guests can easily reach Setauket Neighborhood House which is not far away.
From
US$ 279
/night
View on map20.7 mi from Fire Island20.7 mi from City Center
A few meters away you can enjoy Blackfoot Charters.
7.2
Very good3 reviews
From
US$ 375
/night
View on map20.1 mi from Fire Island20.1 mi from City Center
Walking Figure is 4.2 miles from this villa that offers 4 bedrooms along with a full kitchen.
View on map15.3 mi from Fire Island15.3 mi from City Center
Located off Town of Brookhaven and 0.1 miles from the center of Yaphank, this hotel features 146 rooms and an indoor swimming pool.
From
US$ 120
/night
The Ocean Bay HouseBed & Breakfast
View on map9.9 mi from Fire Island9.9 mi from City Center
Located next to South Shore Nature Center, the venue comprises 9 rooms with pool views.
10.0
Perfect1 review
From
US$ 191
/night
34 Champlain Unit 1Villa
View on map3.8 mi from Fire Island3.8 mi from City Center
Guests at this beachfront venue, located 19 km from Holtsville Ecology Site, can enjoy cycling and fishing.
From
US$ 587
/night
26 DunewayVilla
View on map4.5 mi from Fire Island4.5 mi from City Center
Featuring a play area and a playground which are perfect for kids, this villa is situated 1 km away from the city centre.
From
US$ 1 458
/night
View on map3.8 mi from Fire Island3.8 mi from City Center
Gardiner County Park is 13 km from this villa that offers 4 bedrooms along with a kitchen.
From
US$ 1 188
/night
View on map5.0 mi from Fire Island5.0 mi from City Center
The villa has 4 separate bedrooms together with a full kitchen and is located near Fair Harbor.
From
US$ 1 289
/night
195 Wilmot RoadVilla
View on map4.9 mi from Fire Island4.9 mi from City Center
Located in the beach area of the city, the villa comprises 3 bedrooms and a kitchen for guests' convenience.
From
US$ 312
/night
From
US$ 479
/night
View on map3.8 mi from Fire Island3.8 mi from City Center
View on map5.3 mi from Fire Island5.3 mi from City Center
View on map13.3 mi from Fire Island13.3 mi from City Center
View on map16.4 mi from Fire Island16.4 mi from City Center
From
US$ 648
/night
26 OntarioVilla
View on map3.9 mi from Fire Island3.9 mi from City Center
Offering a full kitchen complete with a microwave oven, a dishwasher and coffee/tea makers, this villa is located close to The Sunken Forest.
From
US$ 1 101
/night
View on map21.8 mi from Fire Island21.8 mi from City Center
Offering a fully-fitted kitchen complete with a microwave, a dishwasher and a washing machine, this villa is located close to Wardenclyffe.
15 SenecaVilla
View on map3.8 mi from Fire Island3.8 mi from City Center
Capt. Rod Fishing Boat is 10 km from this villa that offers 3 bedrooms along with a kitchen.
From
US$ 1 033
/night
A Place In The SunVilla
View on map4.7 mi from Fire Island4.7 mi from City Center
This is a 5-bedroom villa, set in proximity to Dunewood.
From
US$ 644
/night
128 BungalowVilla
View on map4.9 mi from Fire Island4.9 mi from City Center
Located 4.6 km from The Sunken Forest, this villa features a heated swimming pool and is equipped with a fully-fitted kitchen.
From
US$ 2 736
/night
10 CayugaVilla
View on map3.7 mi from Fire Island3.7 mi from City Center
Offering a full kitchen equipped with a microwave, a dishwasher and a washing machine, this villa is set near The Sunken Forest.
From
US$ 1 005
/night
Champlain StreetVilla
View on map3.9 mi from Fire Island3.9 mi from City Center
Located 4.6 km from Clam Pond, this well-equipped villa features a shower and a sofa at a terrace.
From
US$ 273
/night
Robbins Rest RetreatVilla
View on map5.3 mi from Fire Island5.3 mi from City Center
East Islip Marina Park is 8 km from this villa that offers 8 bedrooms along with a fully-fitted kitchen.
From
US$ 1 154
/night
11 Cayuga StreetVilla
View on map3.7 mi from Fire Island3.7 mi from City Center
Offering a fully-fitted kitchen complete with a microwave oven, an electric kettle and a dishwasher, this villa is located close to The Sunken Forest.
From
US$ 774
/night
37 Ocean Bay BlvdVilla
View on map3.9 mi from Fire Island3.9 mi from City Center
Set 3.1 km from The Sunken Forest, this property features 4 bedrooms and a sunny patio with a shower.
From
US$ 1 417
/night
726 Ocean BreezeVilla
View on map4.7 mi from Fire Island4.7 mi from City Center
Featuring a play area and a playground which are perfect for kids, this villa is situated 1 km away from the city centre.
From
US$ 1 914
/night
77 Bay View WalkApartment
View on map3.8 mi from Fire Island3.8 mi from City Center
Long Island Maritime Museum is 9 km from this villa that offers 3 bedrooms along with a fully equipped kitchen.
From
US$ 930
/night
56 EvergreenVilla
View on map4.4 mi from Fire Island4.4 mi from City Center
Located in the beach area of the city, the villa comprises 4 bedrooms and a full kitchen for guests' convenience.
From
US$ 1 023
/night
29 EvergreenVilla
View on map4.5 mi from Fire Island4.5 mi from City Center
Featuring a play area and a playground which are perfect for kids, this villa is situated 1 km away from the city centre.
From
US$ 615
/night
68 Ocean RoadVilla
View on map4.9 mi from Fire Island4.9 mi from City Center
Featuring a patio and 4 bedrooms, the property is set close to The Sunken Forest.
From
US$ 861
/night
603 Bayberry WalkVilla
View on map4.8 mi from Fire Island4.8 mi from City Center
Offering a kitchen equipped with a microwave, a dishwasher and a cooktop, this villa is set near The Sunken Forest.
From
US$ 847
/night
27 Evergreen SeaviewVilla
View on map4.5 mi from Fire Island4.5 mi from City Center
The Sunken Forest is 4 km from this villa that offers 5 bedrooms along with a kitchen.
From
US$ 1 434
/night
140 Ocean RoadVilla
View on map4.9 mi from Fire Island4.9 mi from City Center
Offering a kitchen complete with a microwave, a dishwasher and a fridge, this villa is located close to The Sunken Forest.
From
US$ 818
/night
Saved
Save
Filtering results
Please wait...
75 hotels found