Cottage Rentals in Put-in-Bay from 213 USD/night in June 2023

Get Prices

1-20 out of 76

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

Applied filters

Middle Bass Island Escape Resort Pool And Tiki Bar! Put-in-Bay Exterior photo

Middle Bass Island Escape Resort Pool And Tiki Bar!Villa

6 adults

1 bedroom

1 bed

View on map1.8 mi from City Center

Offering a fully equipped kitchen complete with a microwave oven, a refrigerator and a cooktop, this villa is located close to Aquatic Resource Center.

From US$ 367 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club Rentals Put-in-Bay Exterior photo

Island Club RentalsVilla

10 adults

3 bedrooms

5 beds

View on map1.2 mi from City Center1.0 mi from Stonehenge

Located just 0.7 miles from Perry's Cave, the property provides a picnic area, a swimming pool and a golf course for the convenience of its guests.

7.8

Very good4 reviews

From US$ 380 /nightSelect

Not available

Aunt Jane'S Victorian ManorVilla

12 adults

3 bedrooms

5 beds

500 yd from City Center400 yd from Stonehenge

This 3-bedroom property includes an outdoor swimming pool, and lies in proximity to South Bass Island.

From US$ 628 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club #71Villa

8 adults

1 bedroom

2 beds

1.2 mi from City Center1.0 mi from Stonehenge

Located 20 minutes' walk from the center of Put-in-Bay, the villa features an outdoor pool and a golf course on its premises.

From US$ 234 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club #93Villa

8 adults

1 bedroom

2 beds

1.3 mi from City Center1.1 mi from Stonehenge

Located just 1.9 km from Lake Erie Islands Historical Society in Put-in-Bay, this villa offers an outdoor swimming pool and a golf course.

From US$ 380 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club #80Villa

8 adults

1 bedroom

2 beds

1.3 mi from City Center1.1 mi from Stonehenge

Placed a 30-minute walk from Put-in-Bay's city centre, the villa features an outdoor swimming pool and a golf course.

From US$ 351 /nightSelect

Not available

Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #103 Exterior photo

Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #103Villa

6 adults

1 bedroom

2 beds

1.0 mi from City Center1300 yd from Stonehenge

Located near a tube station and minutes away from Chocolate Museum, this villa offers an outdoor pool and a golf course for guests' comfort.

From US$ 760 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club #53Villa

8 adults

1 bedroom

2 beds

1.2 mi from City Center1.0 mi from Stonehenge

Located just 1.8 km from Alaskan Birdhouse Wildlife Museum in Put-in-Bay, this villa offers an outdoor swimming pool and a golf course.

From US$ 234 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club #98Villa

10 adults

1 bedroom

2 beds

1.3 mi from City Center1.1 mi from Stonehenge

Placed a 30-minute walk from Put-in-Bay's city centre, the villa features an outdoor swimming pool and a golf course.

From US$ 380 /nightSelect

Not available

Middle Bass Island Home - Pool And Hot Tub Access! Put-in-Bay Exterior photo

Middle Bass Island Home - Pool And Hot Tub Access!Villa

6 adults

1 bedroom

1 bed

1.8 mi from City Center

Offering a kitchen equipped with a microwave oven, a fridge and kitchenware, this villa is set near Stonehenge.

From US$ 213 /nightSelect

Not available

Aunt Jane'S TwoVilla

20 adults

5 bedrooms

5 beds

600 yd from City Center400 yd from Stonehenge

Situated 8 km from Catawba Island Historical Society in Put-in-Bay, this venue features an outdoor pool.

From US$ 329 /nightSelect

Not available

All Star Ohio HouseVilla

22 adults

6 bedrooms

7 beds

500 yd from City Center500 yd from Stonehenge

Island General Food Market is just 600 feet from the villa, where you can try canoeing, mini golf and fisheries.

From US$ 900 /nightSelect

Not available

Middle Bass Cabin With Grill And Lagoon Access!Villa

6 adults

2 bedrooms

2 beds

1.8 mi from City Center

Offering a kitchen complete with a microwave, a fridge and kitchenware, this villa is located close to Chocolate Museum.

From US$ 227 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club #51Villa

8 adults

1 bedroom

3 beds

1.2 mi from City Center1.0 mi from Stonehenge

Placed 3 km from the centre of Put-in-Bay, the property has superb leisure facilities, including an outdoor swimming pool and a golf course.

From US$ 292 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club #22Villa

8 adults

1 bedroom

1 bed

1.2 mi from City Center1800 yd from Stonehenge

Situated 1200 metres from Chocolate Museum in Put-in-Bay, this venue features an outdoor pool and a golf course.

From US$ 263 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club #5Villa

8 adults

3 bedrooms

4 beds

1.2 mi from City Center1.0 mi from Stonehenge

Set 1.8 km from Alaskan Birdhouse Wildlife Museum in Put-in-Bay, this property features an outdoor pool and a golf course.

From US$ 292 /nightSelect

Not available

Put-In-Bay Poolview Condo #7 Exterior photo

Put-In-Bay Poolview Condo #7Villa

8 adults

2 bedrooms

2 beds

1.0 mi from City Center1300 yd from Stonehenge

Placed a 20-minute walk from Put-in-Bay's city centre, the villa features an outdoor swimming pool and a golf course.

From US$ 409 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club #104Villa

10 adults

1 bedroom

2 beds

1.2 mi from City Center1.1 mi from Stonehenge

Located off South Bass Island in Put-in-Bay, this villa offers its guests access to an outdoor pool and a golf course.

From US$ 468 /nightSelect

Not available

Island Club #3Villa

10 adults

3 bedrooms

5 beds

1.2 mi from City Center1.0 mi from Stonehenge

Located just 1.8 km from Aquatic Resource Center in Put-in-Bay, this villa offers an outdoor pool and a golf course.

From US$ 468 /nightSelect

Not available

Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #207 Exterior photo

Put-In-Bay Waterfront Condo #207Villa

12 adults

4 bedrooms

4 beds

1.0 mi from City Center1300 yd from Stonehenge

Situated 1050 metres from South Bass Island in Put-in-Bay, this venue features an outdoor pool and a golf course.

From US$ 1 287 /nightSelect

Not available

See more hotels matching your selection criteria:

Filtering results

Please wait...

76 hotels found

FAQs about cottages in Put-in-Bay

Check 8 answers in our FAQ if you are looking for cottages in Put-in-Bay.

What are the best vacation cottages in Put-in-Bay?

Travelers who are looking for the best private accommodation, Booked.net offers 3 deals to pick from. Another fantastic option is Island Club Rentals offering a golf course, a seasonal outdoor pool and hiking along with a seasonal outdoor pool and the outdoor swimming pool on site. It costs 270US$ per night.

What are the best cheap cottages to rent in Put-in-Bay?

If you're on budget, Booked.net offers 3 options to pick from. Alternatively, you may book Island Club Rentals rated 8.0/10 for 270US$ per night. It offers an outdoor swimming pool, a golf course and mini golf.

What are the top luxury cottages for rent in Put-in-Bay?

If you're interested in a deluxe Put-in-Bay getaway, Booked.net offers 4 upscale options. You may book Aunt Jane'S Victorian Manor for 575US$ per night. It's located a 5-minute walk from Mother of Sorrows Catholic Church. Travelers can enjoy a sitting area, a dining area and flat-screen TV in the rooms.

What are best Put-in-Bay cottages for rent next to Perry's Cave?

You may like Waterfront Condo #107, a cool option with an outdoor swimming pool and a golf course on site. It will cost you about 936US$ per night.

What Put-in-Bay cottages allow dogs?

If you want to stay in Put-in-Bay with your pet, Booked.net offers 5 options to pick from. One of the best dog-friendly options is Aunt Jane'S Victorian Manor, featuring canoeing, hiking and mini golf. It costs about 575US$ per night.

What Put-in-Bay cottages featuring a swimming pool?

To relax around a pool, Booked.net offers 66 accommodations to pick from. We recommend Island Club Rentals with a seasonal outdoor pool, hiking and mini golf on site. It costs 270US$ per night. Alternatively, find out Island Club #3 for 321US$ per night. It features an outdoor swimming pool and a golf course on site.

What are the top waterfront cottages in Put-in-Bay?

We recommend Island Club #71 offering an outdoor swimming pool, a golf course and hiking on site for 263US$ per night. It's set a 5-minute walk from the beach.

What are the top romantic cottages for couples in Put-in-Bay?

To visit Put-in-Bay during a romantic trip, travelers usually pick one of 3 top-ranked cottages. For instance, book Island Club Rentals set 15 minutes' walk from. Perry's Cave. It provides a seasonal outdoor pool and an outdoor swimming pool, as well as a seasonal outdoor pool, hiking and mini golf on site. Also find out Island Club #98 with an outdoor swimming pool and a golf course on site. It costs 497US$ per night.