Cottage Rentals in Shelter Island from 160 USD/night in January 2023 — Booked.net

Booked.netFind a better deal

Enter hotel here...
My bookings1
- English
  ×
  Popular languages
  - English
  - Deutsch
  - Español
  All languages
  - العربية
  - Български
  - Bahasa Malaysia
  - 简体中文
  - Čeština
  - Dansk
  - Deutsch
  - English
  - English (Canada)
  - English
  - Español
  - Español (Mexico)
  - Français
  - Ελληνικά
  - עברית
  - Italiano
  - 日本語
  - 한국어
  - Magyar
  - Nederlands
  - Norsk
  - Polski
  - Português
  - Português
  - Română
  - Русский
  - Русский
  - Svenska
  - Türkçe
  - Українська
  - Bahasa Indonesia
  - Thai
  - Tiếng Việt
  No languages found
  
  Try changing your search
- USD(U.S. dollar)
  ×
  Popular currencies
  
  All currencies
  
  No currencies found
  
  Try changing your search
Support
- Contact us
- Read our FAQs
Company
- About Us
- Privacy Policy

1-20 out of 52

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

Applied filters

Sunset Beach Villa Shelter Island Exterior photo

Sunset Beach Villa Shelter IslandVilla

View on map1.6 mi from City Center400 yd from City Center

#20 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

Similar properties near Shelter Island

East Marion Home Walk To Beach-3 Mi To Greenport! Exterior photo

East Marion Home Walk To Beach-3 Mi To Greenport!Villa

8 adults

3 bedrooms

3 beds

View on map4.3 mi from Shelter Island4.3 mi from City Center

Offering a fully equipped kitchen complete with a microwave, a dishwasher and a refrigerator, this villa is located close to Bible Baptist Church.

#19 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

From US$ 273 /nightSelect

Not available

Sag Harbor Beauty Villa Exterior photo

Sag Harbor BeautyVilla

View on map4.7 mi from Shelter Island4.7 mi from City Center

Located 1 miles from Sag Harbor, this villa offers a patio, a private beach area and a garden together with 3 bathrooms.

#18 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

From US$ 689 /nightSelect

Not available

Victorian Seasons Stirling Villa East Marion Exterior photo

Victorian Seasons StirlingVilla

View on map3.2 mi from Shelter Island3.2 mi from City Center

Situated in East Marion next to Greenport Fire, this property features cots, playpens and board games for families with children.

#17 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

From US$ 1 450 /nightSelect

Not available

Breakwater By Rovetravel Serene Escape W Peloton Villa Sag Harbor Exterior photo

Breakwater By Rovetravel Serene Escape W PelotonVilla

View on map5.5 mi from Shelter Island5.5 mi from City Center

#16 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

Greenport Getaway Villa Exterior photo

Greenport GetawayVilla

View on map3.6 mi from Shelter Island3.6 mi from City Center

#15 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

Coves Bay Beauty Villa Sag Harbor Exterior photo

Coves Bay BeautyVilla

View on map4.2 mi from Shelter Island4.2 mi from City Center

#14 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

East Hampton Exquisite Villa Exterior photo

East Hampton ExquisiteVilla

View on map9.3 mi from Shelter Island9.3 mi from City Center

#13 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

From US$ 2 107 /nightSelect

Not available

Deerfield Dream House Villa Sag Harbor Exterior photo

Deerfield Dream HouseVilla

View on map7.3 mi from Shelter Island7.3 mi from City Center

#12 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

Bay Point Perfection Villa Sag Harbor Exterior photo

Bay Point PerfectionVilla

View on map4.6 mi from Shelter Island4.6 mi from City Center

#11 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

The Great Escape - Hamptons Serene Family Favorite Villa Sagaponack Exterior photo

The Great Escape - Hamptons Serene Family FavoriteVilla

View on map8.7 mi from Shelter Island8.7 mi from City Center

#10 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

Noyac Path Estate Villa Water Mill Exterior photo

Noyac Path EstateVilla

View on map8.2 mi from Shelter Island8.2 mi from City Center

#9 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

From US$ 10 949 /nightSelect

Not available

Meadowood Manor By Rovetravel Entertainment Galore Villa Sag Harbor Exterior photo

Meadowood Manor By Rovetravel Entertainment GaloreVilla

View on map5.7 mi from Shelter Island5.7 mi from City Center

#8 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

From US$ 315 /nightSelect

Not available

Modern On 9Th Villa Greenport Exterior photo

Modern On 9ThVilla

View on map2.6 mi from Shelter Island2.6 mi from City Center

#7 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

Wheelock Wonder Villa East Hampton Exterior photo

Wheelock WonderVilla

View on map8.6 mi from Shelter Island8.6 mi from City Center

#6 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

Beachwood Cove By Rovetravel Bbq & Wfh Desks Villa East Hampton Exterior photo

Beachwood Cove By Rovetravel Bbq & Wfh DesksVilla

View on map6.9 mi from Shelter Island6.9 mi from City Center

#5 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

From US$ 670 /nightSelect

Not available

Wonderful 6 Bedroom Home At Hamptons Noyack Exterior photo

Wonderful 6 Bedroom Home At HamptonsVilla

View on map6.8 mi from Shelter Island6.8 mi from City Center

#4 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

Sag Harbor Hideaway Villa Exterior photo

Sag Harbor HideawayVilla

View on map5.9 mi from Shelter Island5.9 mi from City Center

#3 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

From US$ 346 /nightSelect

Not available

112 Northwest Path Villa Sagaponack Exterior photo

112 Northwest PathVilla

View on map7.9 mi from Shelter Island7.9 mi from City Center

#2 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

Bridgehampton Gem Villa Exterior photo

Bridgehampton GemVilla

View on map7.2 mi from Shelter Island7.2 mi from City Center

#1 of the top-rated cottages in Shelter Island

Select

Not available

See more hotels matching your selection criteria:

1
2
3

Filtering results

Please wait...

52 hotels found