Cottage Rentals in Sag Harbor from 212 USD/night in February 2023

1-20 out of 21

Sort by:

Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Guest rating: high to low
Popularity: high to low

Applied filters

View on map1.2 mi from City Center1.0 mi from Off the Rocker

Located 1 miles from Sag Harbor, this villa offers a patio, a private beach area and a garden together with 3 bathrooms.

#20 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 688 /nightSelect

Not available

Bay Point PerfectionVilla

View on map1.0 mi from City Center1500 yd from Bay Street Theatre

#19 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

Select

Not available

The Parkside Retreat In NoyacVilla

6 adults

3 bedrooms

3 beds

3.2 mi from City Center

Offering a fully equipped kitchen complete with a dishwasher, a refrigerator and a washing machine, this villa is located close to Ark Project Inc.

#18 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 620 /nightSelect

Not available

Coves Bay BeautyVilla

1.3 mi from City Center1.0 mi from Bay Street Theatre

#17 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

Select

Not available

Villa Ebrar - Luxury With Pool Sag Harbor Exterior photo

Villa Ebrar - Luxury With PoolVilla

3 adults

4 bedrooms

4 beds

3.5 mi from City Center

Located 1 miles from Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge, the villa features a cable flat-screen and a flat screen TV.

#16 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

Select

Not available

Colonial Gem Near The BayVilla

1200 yd from City Center1500 yd from Off the Rocker

#15 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 1 274 /nightSelect

Not available

Villa KeylimeVilla

9 adults

5 bedrooms

5 beds

1.1 mi from City Center1.2 mi from Bay Street Theatre

Offering a kitchen equipped with a microwave oven, a dishwasher and a fridge, this villa is set near Out of the Closet.

#14 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 386 /nightSelect

Not available

Cozy Sag Harbor House Rental - Walk To Beach!Villa

2.5 mi from City Center

#13 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

Select

Not available

Meadowood Manor By Rovetravel Entertainment GaloreVilla

3.5 mi from City Center

#12 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 315 /nightSelect

Not available

Cottage In The Hamptons Sag Harbor Exterior photo

Cottage In The HamptonsVilla

1200 yd from City Center1400 yd from Bay Street Theatre

#11 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 212 /nightSelect

Not available

John Street On The CoveVilla

1400 yd from City Center1300 yd from Off the Rocker

The Hampton Classic is 4 miles from this villa that offers 3 bedrooms along with an equipped kitchenette area.

#10 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 700 /nightSelect

Not available

Villa Kimaal - Luxury With Pool Sag Harbor Exterior photo

Villa Kimaal - Luxury With PoolVilla

8 adults

5 bedrooms

5 beds

1700 yd from City Center1100 yd from Custom House

Located about 1 miles from Schiavoni's Market Inc, the villa offers accommodation for 8 guests.

#9 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 3 816 /nightSelect

Not available

Sag Harbor HideawayVilla

1400 yd from City Center1700 yd from Off the Rocker

#8 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 232 /nightSelect

Not available

Villa Zainip - Luxury With Pool Sag Harbor Exterior photo

Villa Zainip - Luxury With PoolVilla

8 adults

5 bedrooms

5 beds

4.7 mi from City Center

Located 1 miles from path continues, this villa offers a cable flat-screen and a flat screen TV together with 4 bathrooms.

#7 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 1 450 /nightSelect

Not available

Vibrant Sag Harbor Village Exterior photo

Vibrant Sag Harbor VillageVilla

800 yd from City Center1000 yd from Off the Rocker

#6 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

Select

Not available

Noyack Bay BeautyVilla

2.5 mi from City Center

#5 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

Select

Not available

Sag Harbor SerenityVilla

400 yd from City Center300 yd from Bay Street Theatre

Being within 1.4 miles of Foster Memorial Town Beach, this villa features a sunny patio.

#4 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 276 /nightSelect

Not available

Deerfield Dream HouseVilla

4.6 mi from City Center

#3 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

Select

Not available

Breakwater By Rovetravel Serene Escape W PelotonVilla

600 yd from City Center900 yd from Off the Rocker

#2 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

Select

Not available

Villa Life Style Sag Harbor Exterior photo

Villa Life StyleVilla

8 adults

4 bedrooms

4 beds

1.6 mi from City Center1.6 mi from City Center

Located about 1.7 miles from Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum, the villa offers accommodation for 8 guests.

#1 of the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor

From US$ 2 176 /nightSelect

Not available

See more hotels matching your selection criteria:

Filtering results

Please wait...

21 hotels found

FAQs about cottages in Sag Harbor

Check 6 answers in our FAQ if you are looking for cottages in Sag Harbor.

What are the top-rated cottages in Sag Harbor?

Travelers who are searching for the best private accommodation, Booked.net offers 7 deals to pick from. One of the best vacation cottages is Villa Machis, which costs 2088US$ per night and offers an indoor swimming pool and video games on site.

What are the top budget cottages to rent in Sag Harbor?

We recommend Villa Keylime at the cost of 1278US$ per night. This cool option provides an indoor swimming pool, cribs and video games on site.

What are the most popular pet-friendly cottages in Sag Harbor?

If you want to stay in Sag Harbor with your pet, Booked.net offers 4 options to pick from. One of the best dog-friendly options is Villa Machis, featuring an indoor swimming pool, video games and bar.

What are the best cottages with a swimming pool in Sag Harbor?

To relax around a pool, Booked.net offers 7 accommodations to pick from. We recommend Villa Machis with an indoor swimming pool, video games and bar on site. It costs 2088US$ per night.

What are the most popular waterfront cottages in Sag Harbor?

You may check Villa Keylime, a perfect vacation cottage offering an indoor swimming pool, cribs and video games on site. It costs 1278US$ per night.

What romantic cottages for couples in Sag Harbor are the best?

To visit Sag Harbor during a romantic trip, travelers usually pick one of 7 top-ranked cottages. You may check Villa Machis with an indoor swimming pool and video games on site. It costs 2088US$ per night.