Shelter Island NY Hotels

    • Sort by:
    • Popularity
    • Price
    • Star rating
    • Guest rating
Legend
Legend
  • Hotels on page
  •  
  • Other hotels
  • Airports
  • Underground stations
  • Train stations
  • Parks
  • Tourist attractions
  • Museums
  • Convention centers
  • Stadiums
  • Food and meals
  • General

Hover above the icons to see hotel photo and details.

Click the hotel to go to the main hotel page.

  • 81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11964, Map
    9.2
    Superb
    Based on 1 reviews
    The Pridwin Hotel photos Exterior
    Free Wi-Fi

    Free Wi-Fi in public areas

    Parking

    On-site car park

    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    A la carte restaurant

    Swimming pool

    Seasonal outdoor pool

    TV

    Leisure/ TV room

    Sports activities

    Table tennis

    Billiard tables

    Cycling

    Golf course

    Tennis court

    Water sports

    The 3-star The Pridwin Hotel enjoys its location near to the beach. This hotel is about 4. More details

    From
    US$374
    per night
    Not available
  • 35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11965, Map
    7.6
    Fabulous
    Based on 21 reviews
    Sunset Beach photos Exterior
    Internet

    Free internet access

    Parking
    Luggage storage
    24-hour services

    24-hour reception

    Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    Restaurant

    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Sports activities

    Golf course

    Pets allowed

    The 4-star Sunset Beach Hotel lies within 22 km from General William Hart House. The hotel opened its doors in 1970 and was remodeled in 2010. More details

    From
    US$595
    per night
    Not available
  • 7 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11965, Map
    Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Parking

    On-site car park

    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Food/ Drinks

    Restaurant buffet

    Spa and relaxation

    Massage

    Laundry
    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island is located in a natural area of Shelter Island, about 10 km away from Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum. Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island welcomes guests to its non-smoking rooms since 1902. More details

    From
    US$393
    per night
    Not available
  • 6 Sunshine Road, Shelter Island, United States, 11964, Map
    Sunshine Bungalow Shelter Island Retreat - 2Bedrooms, 3Beds photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Free parking
    Kitchen facilities
    Air conditioning
    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Food/ Drinks

    Outdoor dining area

    No pets allowed

    Sunshine Bungalow Shelter Island Retreat - 2Bedrooms, 3Beds is a villa in Shelter Island within short distance of East End Seaport Maritime Museum, Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum and Greenport Farmers\' Market featuring a free car park and a garden. More details

    Not available
  • Hotels near Shelter Island
  • 7850 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939, Map
    3.9 mi from Shelter Island
    8.0
    Fabulous
    Based on 9 reviews
    The Blue Inn At North Fork photos Facilities
    Wi-Fi
    Parking

    On-site car park

    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Food/ Drinks

    Restaurant

    Swimming pool

    Outdoor swimming pool

    Spa and relaxation

    Jacuzzi

    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    The 3-star The Blue Inn At North Fork enjoys its location near to the beach. The Blue Inn At North Fork was opened in 1960 and offers classic rooms. More details

    From
    US$203
    per night
    Not available
  • 9680 North Bayview Road, Southold, United States, 11971, Map
    3.6 mi from Shelter Island
    A Walk In The Woods Bed And Breakfast photos Exterior
    Free Wi-Fi

    Free Wi-Fi in public areas

    Free parking
    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Sports activities

    Billiard tables

    Pets allowed
    Air conditioning

    A Walk In The Woods Bed And Breakfast is located in a busy area of Southold, about 8 km away from East End Seaport Maritime Museum. General William Hart House is about 28 km from the hotel. More details

    From
    US$266
    per night
    Not available
  • The Greenporter Hotel3 star hotel

    326 Front Street, Greenport, United States, 11944, Map
    2.7 mi from Shelter Island
    8.8
    Superb
    Based on 3 reviews
    The Greenporter Hotel photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi

    The 3-star The Greenporter Hotel places guests abound 25 km from Long Island Railroad. The venue is 21 km away from General William Hart House. More details

    Not available
  • 104 Bay Avenue, Greenport, United States, 11944, Map
    2.7 mi from Shelter Island
    The Stirling House B&B Greenport photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Free parking
    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Food/ Drinks

    Outdoor dining area

    Snack bar

    TV

    Leisure/ TV room

    Kitchen facilities

    Electric kettle

    Check-in/ Check-out

    Express check-in/ -out

    VIP check-in/ -out

    The Stirling House B&B Greenport offers an unique accommodation with a baggage storage and a designated smoking area. The property is 10 minutes' walk from center of Greenport. More details

    From
    US$295
    per night
    Not available
  • 23 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights, United States, 11965, Map
    1.4 mi from Shelter Island
    The Chequit Inn photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Parking

    On-site car park

    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    A la carte restaurant

    Check-in/ Check-out

    VIP check-in/ -out

    Sports activities

    Golf course

    Breakfast

    Continental breakfast

    Situated about 20 minutes' walk from Railroad Museum of Long Island, the unique The Chequit Inn offers a sun deck, a shared lounge and a golf course. The property opened in 1872 and features historic architecture. More details

    From
    US$335
    per night
    Not available
  • 8985 Main Road, P.O. Box 574, East Marion, United States, 11939, Map
    4.0 mi from Shelter Island
    Quintessentials Bed And Breakfast And Spa photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Parking

    On-site car park

    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Food/ Drinks

    Outdoor dining area

    Snack bar

    Spa and relaxation

    Jacuzzi

    Massage

    Turkish bath

    Spa & wellness centre

    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Kitchen facilities

    Electric kettle

    Quintessentials Bed And Breakfast And Spa is a 5-star business accommodation to stay in East Marion. The property is set 10 minutes' walk of the city center. More details

    From
    US$326
    per night
    Not available
  • 714 Main Street, Greenport, United States, 11944, Map
    3.1 mi from Shelter Island
    7.4
    Very good
    Based on 6 reviews
    Townsend Manor Inn photos Exterior
    Free Wi-Fi

    Free Wi-Fi in public areas

    Free parking
    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    A la carte restaurant

    Snack bar

    Swimming pool

    Outdoor swimming pool

    Laundry
    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Townsend Manor Inn is 1050 meters away from Railroad Museum of Long Island. The building was renovated in 2005. More details

    From
    US$230
    per night
    Not available
  • 31 West Water Street, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963, Map
    5.1 mi from Shelter Island
    Baron'S Cove photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Parking

    On-site car park

    Luggage storage
    24-hour services

    24-hour reception

    Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    A la carte restaurant

    Fitness/ Gym

    Fitness centre

    Swimming pool

    Seasonal outdoor pool

    Indoor swimming pool

    Spa and relaxation

    Massage

    Spa & wellness centre

    Baron'S Cove Hotel is a 4-star property providing a comfortable accommodation with laundry, room service and newspaper service. Operating in Sag Habor since 1956, this hotel features historic architecture and modern comforts. More details

    From
    US$301
    per night
    Not available
  • 8900 Main Road, East Marion, United States, 11939, Map
    4.1 mi from Shelter Island
    9.4
    Exceptional
    Based on 22 reviews
    Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Parking

    On-site car park

    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Food/ Drinks

    Restaurant buffet

    Picnic area/ Tables

    Shuttle

    Paid shuttle service

    Spa and relaxation

    Jacuzzi

    Massage

    Spa & wellness centre

    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    The 2-star Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast is situated a mere 19 km away from General William Hart House. The deluxe hotel represents Victorian architecture in East Marion. More details

    From
    US$320
    per night
    Not available
  • 765 Rt 114, Sag Harbor, United States, 11963, Map
    6.5 mi from Shelter Island
    Forever Bungalows photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Parking

    On-site car park

    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    Outdoor dining area

    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Kitchen facilities

    Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

    Check-in/ Check-out

    Express check-in/ -out

    VIP check-in/ -out

    Offering view over Montauk Point Lighthouse, which is 19 km away, Forever Bungalows is a quiet hotel featuring free self-parking and a golf course. The building was renovated in 2012. More details

    From
    US$408
    per night
    Not available
  • 61475 Route 48, Greenport, United States, 11944, Map
    3.5 mi from Shelter Island
    Cliffside Resort Condominiums - Greenport photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Parking

    On-site car park

    24-hour services
    Babysitting
    Swimming pool

    Seasonal outdoor pool

    Air conditioning
    Private beach
    Spa and relaxation

    Massage

    Cliffside Resort Condominiums - Greenport is a good accommodation choice in Greenport. The venue is 21 km away from General William Hart House. More details

    From
    US$415
    per night
    Not available
  • 25-500 Main Road, East Marion, United States, Map
    5.9 mi from Shelter Island
    Orient Inn photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Parking

    On-site car park

    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Sports activities

    Hiking

    Cycling

    Canoeing

    Fishing

    Breakfast

    In-room breakfast

    Pets allowed

    The 4-star Orient Inn places guests abound 8 km from East End Seaport Maritime Museum. The property is situated 8 km away from Railroad Museum of Long Island. More details

    From
    US$325
    per night
    Not available
  • 817 Main Street , Greenport, United States, Map
    3.2 mi from Shelter Island
    Fordham House photos Exterior
    Free Wi-Fi
    Parking

    Car park

    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Breakfast

    The 3-star hotel Fordham House provides a designer accommodation and gives a quick access to Railroad Museum of Long Island, which is around 1150 meters away. The city center is about 10 minutes on foot. More details

    Not available
  • 209 Front Street, Greenport, United States, 11944, Map
    2.6 mi from Shelter Island
    The Harborfront Inn photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Free parking
    Luggage storage
    24-hour services

    24-hour reception

    Fitness/ Gym

    Fitness centre

    Swimming pool

    Seasonal outdoor pool

    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Elevator

    Lift

    The central The Harborfront Inn provides guests with a safe deposit box, a vending machine and a lift. The city center is about 10 minutes on foot. More details

    From
    US$318
    per night
    Not available
  • 300 Main Street, Greenport, United States, Map
    2.7 mi from Shelter Island
    American Beech photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Parking
    Luggage storage
    24-hour services
    Food/ Drinks

    Bar/ Lounge area

    A la carte restaurant

    Snack bar

    Spa and relaxation

    Massage

    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Check-in/ Check-out

    Express check-in/ -out

    VIP check-in/ -out

    American Beech Hotel is a good accommodation choice in Greenport. The venue is 23 km away from Crystal Lake Town Park. More details

    From
    US$368
    per night
    Not available
  • 1031 Noyac Road, Southampton, United States, 11968, Map
    8.6 mi from Shelter Island
    Southampton 6 Bed With Pool - Newly Renovated! photos Exterior
    Wi-Fi
    Free parking
    Kitchen facilities

    Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

    Air conditioning
    TV

    Flat-screen TV

    Laundry
    Food/ Drinks

    Outdoor dining area

    Spa and relaxation

    Jacuzzi

    Southampton 6 Bed With Pool - Newly Renovated! Holiday home is situated a mere 9 km away from The Thomas Halsey Homestead. More details

    From
    US$2 000
    per night
    Not available

Filtering results

Please wait...

^
28 hotels found
Go to map view
Go to list view
Cities nearby
  • (9)
  • (5)
  • (5)
  • (4)
  • (3)
  • (1)
  • (1)
Star rating
Accommodation type
  • (22)
  • (6)
Price
  • (6)
  • (1)
  • (21)
Average rating
  • (2)
  • (2)
  • (1)
Nearby
  • (4)
  • Show more
Airports
  • (5)
Hotel type
  • (5)
  • (2)
  • (1)
  • (1)
  • (1)
Search by name
Amenities
  • (17)
  • (10)
  • (10)
  • (7)
  • (6)
  • (5)
  • (5)
  • Show more
Room facilities
  • (6)
  • (3)
Services
  • (2)
  • (3)
  • (2)
  • (2)
  • (3)
Brands
  • (1)