Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina  3 stars

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, United States, 11954  show mapSave
  • Overview
  • Rooms & Availability
  • Location
  • Guest reviews
  • Facilities


The 3-star Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina is located within the pristine beach. The designer hotel was built in 1929 and refurbished in 2009.

This hotel is situated 1.8km away from Theodore Roosevelt County Park, Gin Beach and Montauk Downs State Park. Montauk Racquet Club, Gosman's Dock and Lake Montauk in Montauk are located nearby.

The hotel is set next to a lighthouse and museums.

85 minutes' drive from New Haven airport.


This property offers 105 air-conditioned guestrooms complete with individual climate control, a wooden balcony, satellite TV, a patio and a laptop-size safe. They come with a fridge and coffee/tea makers as well as bathrooms with complimentary toiletries, bathrobes and a hairdryer.


Breakfast is served in the lounge each morning. The 24-hour restaurant serves American dishes. The lobby bar stocks gins to enjoy in a casual atmosphere.

All visitors are offered a full breakfast for a fee. 


Guests will appreciate a safe deposit box, a vending machine and free parking as well as find a meeting room, a business center and conference facilities useful for work.


Guests are provided with an outdoor swimming pool, an indoor swimming pool and a tennis court on site as well as a sauna, a wellness center and shiatsu massage for relaxation. Such sports activities as golf, volleyball and fishing are provided on-site.


Wireless internet is available in public areas and is free of charge.

Guest Parking

Free Public hotel parking is possible on site.

Year renovated   2009.  Number of rooms   106.

City Center Montauk - 2.4 mi
Airports New Haven (HVN) - 51.4 mi, T. F. Green Airport (PVD) - 52.4 mi
Restaurants Star Island Grill (cuisine: American, Seafood, Asian fusion) - 600 ft, Gulf Coast Kitchen at the Montauk Yacht Club - 700 ft
Beaches Gosman's Dock - 1000 ft
This field is required.
Email not defined
Very Bad Excellent
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Rate this hotel

General information



First Name
To get your review moderated and published, please read our Terms and Conditions.


  • Parking
  • Safe deposit box
  • Car rental
  • Currency exchange
  • Elevator
  • ATM/cash machine
  • Concierge desk
  • Storage space
  • Gift shop
  • 24-Hour Front Desk
  • Front desk
  • VIP room facilities
  • Newspapers/magazines
  • Vending Machines
  • Trouser Press
  • Spa & wellness center
  • Laundry
Dining facilities
  • Bar/lounge
  • Restaurant
  • In-room breakfast
Business facilities
  • Business center
Meeting facilities
  • Meeting/banquet facilities
  • Meeting room
Children's facilities
  • Children's play area
  • Game room
Facilities for people with disabilities
  • Rooms/facilities for people with disabilities
Leisure and relaxation facilities
  • Outdoor pool
  • Indoor swimming pool
  • Sauna
  • Fitness center
  • Golf
  • Fishing
  • Tennis court
  • Hot tub
  • Shiatsu massage
Room view
  • Sea view
  • Courtyard view
  • Lake view
  • Water view
Room facilities
  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Air conditioning
  • Room service
  • Heating
  • Tea and Coffee Facilities
  • Ironing facilities
  • Smoking
  • Patio
  • Terrace
  • Dressing area
Living Area
  • Sitting area
  • Hair dryer
  • Private bathroom
  • Cable TV
  • Satellite TV
  • LCD TV
  • AM/FM alarm clock
  • Telephone
  • Internet access
  • CD player



from  4 pm


until  11 am

Children and extra beds
  • Maximum capacity of extra beds in a room is 1. 

Do you manage this property? Add your hotel to drive more sales or use badges to increase conversion rate at your website.

Premium Room
Check Prices
Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Premium Room
Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Premium Room
Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Premium Room
Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Premium Room
Bed type: Double beds or King Size bed
Size: 360 sq. feet
View: Water view
Room facilities
    Guest Room
    Check Prices
    Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Guest Room
    Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Guest Room
    Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Guest Room
    Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Guest Room
    Bed type: Double beds or King Size bed
    Size: 360 sq. feet
    View: Water view, Sea view
    Room facilities
      Check Prices
      Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Bungalow
      Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Bungalow
      Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Bungalow
      Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Bungalow
      Bed type: Double Bed or King Size bed or Double beds
      Size: 360 sq. feet
      View: Courtyard view, Sea view
      Room facilities
        Check Prices
        Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Villa
        Bed type: King Size bed
        Size: 3770 sq. feet
        Room facilities

          Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina LocationWhat's nearby

          • Current hotel
          • Hotels nearby
          • Airports
          • Underground stations
          • Train stations
          • Parks
          • Tourist attractions
          • Museums
          • Convention centers
          • Stadiums
          • Food and meals
          • General

          Hover above the icons to see hotel photo and details.

          Click the hotel to go to the main hotel page.

          What's nearby

          Popular areas
          • City Center
            2.4 mi

          Local Attractions

          • Theodore Roosevelt County Park
            1.1 mi
            Off Montauk Hwy. 3 mi east of Montauk Village, Montauk
          • Montauk Downs State Park
            1.3 mi
            50 S. Fairview Ave., Montauk
          • Navy Road Park
            1.6 mi
            Fort Pond Bay, Montauk
          • Gin Beach
            1.7 mi
            End of East Lake Dr., Montauk
          • Montauk Point State Park
            1.7 mi
            East End of Route 27, Montauk

          Near the hotel

          • Gosman's Dock
            1000 ft
            W Lake Dr, Montauk
          • Lake Montauk
            4600 ft
            Montauk, NY

          Restaurants Nearby

          • Star Island Grill

            86% likes this, based on 56 reviews
            Cuisine: American, Seafood, Asian fusion, Barbecue
            Price Range: USD 11 - USD 31

            600 ft
            Star Island Rd
          • Gulf Coast Kitchen at the Montauk Yacht Club

            Price Range: USD 30 - USD 30

            700 ft
            32 Star Island Road

            Phone: 6316683100

          • West Lake Clam & Chowder House

            76% likes this, based on 88 reviews
            Cuisine: Seafood

            1600 ft
            382 W Lake Dr

            Phone: 631-668-6252

          • Swallow East

            64% likes this, based on 48 reviews
            Cuisine: American

            2600 ft
            436 west lake drive
          • Cross Eyed Clam

            70% likes this, based on 24 reviews
            Cuisine: American, Seafood, Grill, Bar
            Price Range: USD 5 - USD 24

            2600 ft
            440 West Lake Drive

            Phone: 631.668.8065

          Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina Reviews

          Guest reviews are submitted by our customers after their stay at Montauk Yacht Club Resort And Marina

          Average guest rating

          out of 10
          Based on 51 reviews

          Rating by category:


          Individual guest reviews

          • Family with children

            Clean and nice rooms, nice pool area

            First night we stayed in the "Villas" which was not good, the rooms was not so nice. Then next night we moved to the hotel and got a nice room. The problem there was the aircondition, when we turned it on it was so noicy so you could not sleep wiyh it on.

            • Average rating
          • Older travelers

            I liked the nautical theme and the luxury of the rooms and facilities.

            I would have liked to be able to use the indoor pool without the need for supervision.

            • Average rating
          • Family with children


            Poorly managed. Staff confused and slow to respond. Difficulty when checking in, hotel put in wrong stay dates and made me prove it was a mistake. Put us in wrong room told me teservation details not confirmed and subject to change. Little customer service skills requests to front desk mismanaged and not communicated to staff properly. Very condescending. Hotel is not worth the amount charged per night.

            • Average rating
          • Older travelers

            the room was nice and big ...the bathroom was very up to date and very clean and nice big clean new bath towels and plenty of them..the view was great....

            we stayed in a cottage that had an upstairs the people coming in from being out at nite was very noise going up the stairs.and at 545 am on easter the trash company came and emptied the 4 big trash cans...

            • Average rating
          • Couple

            The location is great. We stayed in a villa which was away from main area so it felt removed. We still had water views and were close to the resort spa. We also ate at the resort one night and found the service, food and wine exceptional. Just what we need for a nice relaxing weekend. The rooms have been renovated tastefully and were very comfortable.

            • Average rating
          • Family with children

            The hotel had a great veiw from our room. The room was comfortable.

            The people At the front desk did not inform guest about limited beach passes or all the things that were free for guest to do. outdated book in room room service old menu did not get to go to the pruvate beach of my choice

            • Average rating
          • Couple

            Location was great and they had a small private beach with use of paddle boats and small sailboats included. Bikes were available for a ride through Montauk. The place is pretty inside and well decorated.

            The staff was not hospitable and the people at the front desk were not trained properly to answer our questions or help us with check-in. People do not pay attention to detail - our keys did not work several times, bathroom did not have towel hangers, front desk person lied to us about how much our debit card will be charged and told us it would be $50 old hfee but our card was put on hold for $600+.

            • Average rating
          • Group of friends

            Lovely location and friendly staff

            The room was not as clean as expected, pool had no lounge chairs

            • Average rating
          • Family with children

            We were there for the Feitelberg/Lejeune wedding. The weather challenges of the 2 previous weeks were most extraordinary, but your staff and the weekend weather made up for all the earlier angst. MYC was winding down and some material issues existed like drains and heat were challenges. However, everyone did all that was necessary to accept the circumstances that existed--the staff truly did all they could to please!! Thank you--Joe Feitelberg

            • Average rating
          • Older travelers

            Our comfortable room with the beautiful view. The balcony was terrific. Spa was very good. Location is wonderful. Quiet and peaceful. Food was good, also.

            Music in the dining room was terrible...Sirius radio Coffeehouse channel. Torture! The salon and the gift shop were closed. What a huge disappointment. Most of the staff were very lackadaisical. No real interest in taking good care of us. Just doing the job. Bare minimum. Nice facility, but not a great experience regarding service.

            • Average rating
          • Older travelers

            Located next to a beautiful harbor. Small private beach. Off the main road away from stores and shopping.

            Was labeled right away for booking our room with you. Given a room at the very end of the building. Room was not in working order. Tub was clogged, toilet didnt flush, hole in closet, screen door did not close properly. There was a gap that let bugs in our room. Complained and nothing was done. Once again reminded we booked our room from you. Then when complained to manager our room was changed to a better room.

            • Average rating
          • Older travelers

            Terrible experience and extremely overpriced. We had to change rooms after the first night, person above us kept us up all night long, walking around on old floors. No insulation... Changed our room after much conversation and hesitation to a much nicer room in another building. That room was nice. Good view of the harbor. little balcony. Got to the new room and the toilet did not work.. Called 3 times for assistance to come to the room to help.... Too much money for a run down hotel. Staff was very cold and not helpful in the least.

            • Average rating
          • Family with children

            Unfortunately our stay at MYC was not very pleasing as the room was very uncomfortable. We arrived late at night to a very damp cool room. The carpet and bedding was literally damp to the touch. The room was dark and fairly unwelcoming. The amenities were few, for some reason we had hair conditioner but not shampoo, maybe an oversight but certainly should not have been. I would probably not stay at MYC again but if I did I would make certain we would stay in another kind of room, not the villas. The room was expensive and certainly not worth the price.

            please see above

            • Average rating
          • Single

            The room and bed, in particular, were extremelyncomfortable.

            i found a dirty pair of socks left from the last visitor on the floor near the desk. The refrigerator was not secured inits cubby hole and it kept fallinf g out each time I opened it. It is extremely expensive.

            • Average rating
          • Group of friends

            Our view was spectacular from the porch.

            It was great.

            • Average rating
          Show big map »

          Why book with us?

          Low prices
          Enjoy our best price guarantee and special offers.
          Free cancellations
          Usually cancellations can be made free of charge close to your arrival date (check policies).
          Guaranteed room
          You get instant confirmation directly from the hotel's reservation database.
          Hotels nearby
          The Surf Club
          2 stars
          Sole East
          3 stars
          2 stars
          Sole East Beach
          2 stars
          Driftwood Resort
          3 stars
          Windward Shores
          3 stars
          The Hermitage
          3 stars
          A Wave Inn
          3 stars
          The Hedges Inn
          4 stars
          Ocean House
          5 stars
          380 Inn
          3 stars
          Inn At Mystic
          3 stars
          Bridge Inn
          2 stars
          Econo Lodge
          2 stars
          Quality Inn
          2 stars
          Comfort Inn
          3 stars
          Sunset Beach
          4 stars
          Clarion Inn
          3 stars
          Niantic Motel
          2 stars
          Stardust Motel
          2 stars