Reviews are ordered by language and date with a maximum of 25 reviews.
Great Location but not quite up there!
| Average rating: |
 |
4.6 |
Guest name: bluewhite, australia
Guest type: Honeymoon
stayed in Jul 2008
For some time I had wanted to stay at the Shangri-La and a few days over my birthday seemed the perfect opportunity to experience this hotel.
Reception staff were friendly and we were directed to the Horizon Club for exclusive check in which was speedy and efficient.
We booked a Horizon Club Opera King room and were upgraded to a Horizon Club Grand Harbour View room. The room was a good size, very comfortable and well laid out and the view was spectacular! No complaints at all about the room - our TV wasn't working properly and when it was reported it was sorted out without delay. The cd/dvd player was very useful and the stationery/office supplies a very novel and useful addition which I have not encountered anywhere before.
The bathroom was large, well lit and the amenities were luxurious and replaced daily. Compliments go to housekeeping who maintained a great standard even though the once when we called to ask for our room to be serviced while we were at breakfast it wasn't done.
The Horizon Club however is a different story. The evening snacks offered a good selection - however if you stay longer than 2 nights it becomes very repetitive; the staff in the Club are very unattentative, a student/trainee was doing most of the serving, and to get her attention for drinks was a major effort. Plates were not cleared off the table even when she did replenish drinks and this was not only one night but on all 3 nights we were there.
The breakfast selection would have to be the worst I have experienced on a "club" level. I took some smoked salmon and when I asked for black pepper; the server made a point of telling me he would have to go down to the 1st level to get some and did I want him to do so. The same applied to the cream cheese I asked for. I did want him to do so and almost 10 minuted later he appeared with the cream cheese, black pepper and lemon wedges. I cannot understand how the club level breakfast room in a hotel of this category would not have black pepper available!
We chose to go down to the 1st floor for breakfast after that experience and enjoyed the breakfast down there.
Concierge was extremely helpful, as was reception staff. In particular I would like to compliment Ashley who is a great asset to the hotel.
When we first made the booking at the hotel; I called Altitude restaurant to book a table for dinner on the night of my birthday. I was informed that they were not taking bookings due to WYD but that they would take my details and get back to me if they were able to accommodate us. They did get back to me at a later stage to say they were in fact going to be abe to accommodate us and I requested a window table, mentioning that it was a celebration of a special birthday.
I reconfirmed the booking at lunch time on the day and again asked for the window table. I was told that as we had booked a long time in advance the likelyhood was good but that it could not be guaranteed.
When we arrived at the restaurant, our table wasn't ready so we were sent to Horizons bar to have a drink until the table was ready. Although the prices at the time seemed extremely high - on checking with comparable hotels, the prices are on a par with the Sheraton, higher than the Hilton and lower than the Intercontinental.
The service in Altitude was definitely not up to the standard we expected and my main course - when it did arrive after 35 minutes was luke warm at best. I can understand that people eat at Altitude for the view, but when you have the same view from your room the food and service have to stand on their own and both were lacking! The prices of both food and wine in Altitude were surprisingly not excessive though.
The swimming pool, spa and sauna were well maintained and always clean. The service directory lists a steam room as well however this does not exist.
Room service was always friendly and speedy - so no complaints there.
The one night we returned to the hotel at about 10.30pm and there were about 15 people waiting for an elevator on the ground floor. After about 5 minutes I actually asked reception if some of the elevators stopped after a certain hour and just as the clerk was going to check where the elevators were- 2 arrived on the ground floor. At all other times they were very fast so I don't know what the problem was at that time.
Overall I guess I would say that the hotel has great rooms and achieves excellence in some departments. The Horizon Club definitely needs improvement as it brings down the standard of the hotel dramatically. We have stayed ( at club level) at the Sheraton, Hilton, Intercontinental and Harbour Marriott; and I'm not sure that we would choose the Shangri La above the others on a future visit.
My ratings for this hotel are:
5.0 Check in / front desk
5.0 Business service
5.0 Value
2.0 Service
5.0 Rooms
5.0 Location
5.0 Cleanliness
Great choice for Sydney
| Average rating: |
 |
4.4 |
Guest name: marty99, London UK
Guest type: Honeymoon
stayed in Jul 2008
Stayed here for NYE celebrations so slightly late in submitting review. Overall the SL is great choice, providing superb facilities , million dollar views and a prime location. We opted for one of the more expensive Grand Harbour view rooms which do not disappoint , although as mentioned the room furniture was looking a little tired and could do with renewing - however they are spacious and little detracts from the panoramic views. As we were there for New year the hotel was very full and consequently there seemed too many guests in the Club area in terms of seating availability and service - in normal times I am sure this would be fine and again the views and the choice of food and drink made up for this. Ironically the best service was on Jan 1 when the breakfast was moved to the main restaurant. The bar is trendy and also comes with killer views for free. The SL location is unbeatable for tourists and overall I think its a sound choice for a 5 star stay and lived up to our high expectations , having stayed at other SL properties in the Far East.
My ratings for this hotel are:
5.0 Check in / front desk
4.0 Value
4.0 Service
4.0 Rooms
5.0 Location
4.0 Cleanliness
Nice experience!
| Average rating: |
 |
4.9 |
Guest name: ViennaLover, California
Guest type: Young single
stayed in Jul 2008
I was visiting Sydney for a wedding, and had an extra few days for enjoying the sites.
Let's start with the good. The hotel is in an excellent location. 5 minute walk to Circular Quay and into the heart of downtown. The common areas are very nice and clean. If you want a cab, there is a ready supply right outside the entrance. The staff (front desk, concierge, and valet) is helpful and welcoming. The lobby lounge is lively at night with piano music and singing. My room was on the 7th floor and looked out over the Harbour Bridge and Opera House. Lovely view! Although the room was a stones throw from the highway crossing the bridge, the room was quiet without an issue of hearing noise coming through the window. The room itself is spacious and comfortable. Bathrooms are also roomy. Evening turndown service is a nice touch, but to be expected from this hotel class.
As for the negatives, well honestly, not much. The prices are a bit high, but they are not any higher than the other top hotels in the Circular Quay area. There are a lot of business people using this hotel so the evenings can get noisy in the lobby, but it did not bother me. It might for people wanting a resort type feel. The restaurants are expensive, so I did not partake, but the food descriptions looked good.
Overally, a very good hotel. I enjoyed my stay and would not hesitate to return. Please note: Sydney is a beautiful city with wonderful views. If you financially can, spend the extra money on a room with a view. It is worth it!
My ratings for this hotel are:
5.0 Check in / front desk
4.0 Value
5.0 Service
5.0 Rooms
5.0 Location
5.0 Cleanliness
Loved it!
| Average rating: |
 |
5.0 |
Guest name: chrispgr, Athens
Guest type: Honeymoon
stayed in Jul 2008
My wife and myself spent our honeymoon at the Shangri La during December 2008. The check-in was fast and efficient. We stayed at an Horizon Opera House room, which was just fabulous, both for its amenities and views! The staff was rather helpful and the breakfast rich and tasty. Another great plus of this hotel is its location. We managed to book early and we got directly a quote for the above at AUD 375.00 per night, which I consider as an excellent price. Would definitely want to go back again soon!
My ratings for this hotel are:
5.0 Check in / front desk
5.0 Business service
5.0 Value
5.0 Service
5.0 Rooms
5.0 Location
5.0 Cleanliness
Over Priced
| Average rating: |
 |
3.2 |
Guest name: nikas77, Tokyo, Japan
Guest type: Honeymoon
stayed in Jun 2008
My partner and I stayed at the Shangri-La in Sydney for a week at the end of April. Our primary gripes are with the cost of breakfast room service and the availibity of the concierge.
Firstly, the concierge. We'd hired a car and parked it at the hotel. 90% of the time we called the concierge, the number would be engaged. It would take at least 10 mins of repeated dialling to get through. Quite a few times, we would just go down to the lobby and ask for the car there. On one occasion, the concierge on duty asked us why we didn't call first. We told him the line was permanently engaged. He could have said that he would look into it etc; but all we got was a shrug of the shoulders and a look that said 'too bad'. On another ocassion, we'd arrived back at the hotel at around midnight and we couldn't find one of the concierge staff to give the car keys to. We gave them to one of the receptionists. The next day, we called down for the car. They kept us waiting for 20 mins as they couldn't find the car. When they eventually found our keys, we were told that there were 5 other people in front of us. By this time we had been waiting for 30 mins and were late to meet friends. To the hotel's credit, they did refund the days parking - but the lack of urgency by the staff was infuriating. The last point is that cost of the room service breakfast. AU$9.50 for 3 pieces of sliced white bread that I then have to toast myself is a rip-off. Not to mention the AU$12 for half a grapefruit. The cocktails at the Blu Horizon bar are also ridiculous. We paid AU$50/GB?25 for 2 martinis! We live in London and drink in places like the St Martin's Lane Hotel and the Sanderson...The Shangri-La is not in the same league and they charge more for their drinks. Avoid eating and drinking in this hotel at all costs. You can go to a cafe on George St and get toast and a coffee for AU$4.
My ratings for this hotel are:
4.0 Check in / front desk
2.0 Value
2.0 Service
3.0 Rooms
4.0 Location
4.0 Cleanliness