Reviews are ordered by language and date with a maximum of 25 reviews.
Very Pleased With Our Stay
| Average rating: |
 |
4.3 |
Guest name: Snakebit12, Decatur, IL
Guest type: Honeymoon
stayed in Jul 2008
It is funny to see the wide range of reviews...
We booked via Priceline and were quite happy. We arrived very late yet they were able to accomodate our request for a king bed. The room was dated but this is a 130 year old hotel - I would have been dissapointed if it was ultra-modern. What some see at dated, others see as charming.
The room was very comfy, quiet and fairly large. The location was perfect - 3 blocks from the lake and right next to the Adams street subway. We overlooked the "L" on Wabash but never, ever heard any street noise. The lobby was fantastic and there was an energy in the hotel which was fun to experience.
If I had any complaints, they were minor - no coffee machine in the room nor wireless internet (but these both get back to that charrming vs dated view) . Also, one of the 3 elevators that reached the 18th floor was out of commission - so the waits were a bit longer than normal.
The Palmer House was billed as a 4-star...and we concur.
My ratings for this hotel are:
5.0 Check in / front desk
2.0 Business service
5.0 Value
4.0 Service
4.0 Rooms
5.0 Location
5.0 Cleanliness
Beautiful, even though not completed renovation
| Average rating: |
 |
4.5 |
Guest name: JPCtor, Toronto, Ontario
Guest type: Older travelers
stayed in Jul 2008
I stayed here for a wedding with the rest of my family in a renovated room. Becuase we asked for a renovated connecting room we had to wait for 3 hours to get the room. We arrived at around 1:00 PM and check inn was at 3:00 but the room was not ready until 3:30. The front desk staff we originally not very friendly but after they found out we were part of the wedding party, they were very friendly for the entire stay which was odd. The hotel is huge so if a nice quiet hotel is what you want this place is not for you.
The room was really nice with all new furinishings. The room was extremely clean and the bed was extremly comfortable. I could not belive how thin the walls are. You can hear every word that anyone is saying beside you in the hallway and even across the hall in rooms over there. You can also hear if they are in the bathroom as you can hear practically anything. Also try to get a room on the other side from the El. Even being on the other side you could hear it.
The pool/fitness centre was closed for renovation which was a downer but they moved the exercise room into the confrence room and the strange 8.00 fee was waived.
We were given brunch coupons becuase we were part of the wedding and if I had to pay for the food I would have been very upset. The food was absolutely terrible and I counted 2 waiters the whole time I was in there. We checked the menu for lunch and dinner and it was a ripoff. There are tones of places to eat for all three meals all over the area.
Parking was very expensive with valey 45.00 a day.
Chicago is a great city and you can practically get anywhere with public transit and there are always lots of taxis available.
The staff at the door were very nice but the lower concourse was shut down so you have to walk up the staircase to the really nice lobby to get to the elevator.
Overall, it was a really nice stay and we would come again once they complete the renovation and everything is open.
My ratings for this hotel are:
3.0 Check in / front desk
5.0 Business service
4.0 Value
5.0 Service
4.0 Rooms
5.0 Location
5.0 Cleanliness
Don't pay big bucks for this place
| Average rating: |
 |
3.5 |
Guest name: pearcider, Sacramento, CA
Guest type: Honeymoon
stayed in Jul 2008
It has definite pros: the location is great, the lobby is beautiful, the staff was pleasant and professional. However, I have NEVER stayed in such a stripped-down room ANYWHERE. The bathroom is tiny, with a pedestal sink and no counter. Shampoo, conditioner and soap ONLY. No lotion. No shower cap. No coffee. No wet bar. No free internet. Paper-thin walls through which we could easily overhear our neighbors' conversations. The whole place is torn up right now - one entrance open, no fitness center to speak of, workers, tarps, and paint fumes galore. If you're thinking Hilton = four star luxury like I was, you are so wrong. DO NOT pay anything close to rack rate. If I hadn't gotten such a deal on the rate, I would have been furious.
My ratings for this hotel are:
5.0 Check in / front desk
1.0 Business service
3.0 Value
4.0 Service
2.0 Rooms
5.0 Location
4.0 Cleanliness
Never Again
| Average rating: |
 |
2.6 |
Guest name: St_Paul_Poet, St. Paul
A colleague and I booked a room here this past Feb for three nights. We were assured that a room with two double beds would be available but when we got there they told us that there were none but added that a rollaway bed could be brought up to the room for $30 a night. The front desk clerk was one of the most rude and condescending people I've ever dealt with. We turned them down on this offer and asked if we could be put on a waiting list for a new room. I reiterated again that we were assured a room would be available and the clerk told me that she "wasn't sure what Priceline promised" but there were no guarantees. The first night I slept in a chair while my colleague took the bed.
The next day we were given the good news that a room may come up but the catch was we had to be in the hotel to receive the room or it would be given to someone else. We were told that we'd have an answer by 2pm. 2pm came and went, finally we were told at 3:30 that the room would be available after wasting a perfectly good afternoon waiting in the hotel lobby. To add insult to injury, upon checkout, they tried to bill me for the rollaway bed even though it was never brought to our room.
The only bright spot in this whole place was the building itself and the conceirge service, the other staff could learn many lessons from them. They were phenomenal offering great suggestions. I would warn anyone about staying here, especially if they booked through an online travel service. If you book through Expedia, Priceline or the like you'll be treated like a second class guest. A flat out horrible experience.
My ratings for this hotel are:
1.0 Check in / front desk
1.0 Business service
1.0 Value
5.0 Service
3.0 Rooms
3.0 Location
4.0 Cleanliness
Great Location, Rooms could be big or small
| Average rating: |
 |
3.5 |
Guest name: la808, hawaii
Fabulous Location near Millenium Park and State Street shopping.
Stayed here twice for business. First time, my room was a "closet" - the bathroom , closet and the room were so small I barely had room for my suitcase. There was no counter space in the bathroom. 2 people would not have fit in that room. For my last visit, I specially asked for a room NOT like my last stay and bigger than a closet. My room during my latest visit was perfectly fine with 2 beds, nice closet. The bathrooms were still small, but at least there was counter space. It's a dice roll on what kind of room you'll get. Be specific on your request. There are many closet sized rooms in the inventory.
Common areas are very beautiful, but the layout of the lobby is awkward. Check in is on the second floor.
The proximity to the El can bother light sleepers as I could hear the trains.
Convenient to Corner Bakery on same block. CVS across the street. State street shopping around the corner.
Rooms were pricey. I would stay here again only if I received a better deal than a Mag Mile hotel. I would prefer to stay on Michigan Ave for the same price.
My ratings for this hotel are:
3.0 Check in / front desk
3.0 Business service
3.0 Value
3.0 Service
3.0 Rooms
5.0 Location
4.0 Cleanliness